Pros:
- fantastic elevation change
- practice basket by hole 1
- nice Discatcher baskets
- nice full color tee signs at each hole
- dual tees, though shorts can be harder to find
- bathrooms in park but not specifically by disc golf area
- some benches and garbage cans throughout course
- some good next tee signs
- rough is very manageable throughout course
- mostly wooded and very technical with some more open shots on some of the big elevations
- area is mostly dedicated to disc golf and away from other park activities
- really quick round of 18 if you want to get a lot of disc golf in
Cons:
- finding tee 1 is slightly difficult
- rubber tees are just ok
- tee signs have pictures of the fairway instead of a hole map, which is unusual and not as useful
- secondary/short tees have no tee signs
- some ski trail/bike trail interference, differing seasons mean not too many safety hazards
- some navigation issues, but good aids/map
- some may feel it is too short
- some built in stairs would be beneficial (particularly on 15)
Other Thoughts:
City Park is a fantastic course set right in the city of Iron Mountain. You almost wouldn't know you're right there in the city, as this park is a very serene natural setting. I got pretty turned around at first, going too far down the main road into the park and ending up back by hole 17 in a different lot. When you are coming up on the main parts of the park, you have to turn right off the main drive and take a different road way out to the side of the park to get to the disc golf parking area. Then you take the built in stairs up to the top of the hill for hole 1, which isn't completely obvious.
Once I got going, the navigation aids were generally good and I didn't have too much trouble. The walks between 9 and 10 and between 12 and 13 backtrack a bit, potentially leading to people walking back down the fairway, which definitely isn't ideal. Other hazards were limited; the cross country ski trails cross the fairways a bunch, but this won't be an issue unless you're playing in significant snow, which would be a challenge on a course with this many slopes. Some people do use the trails to bike and I had a couple of hazards there with someone riding an electric bike down the middle of the fairway.
I played The Tailings in Iron River the same day as this course, and while both are fantastic, I think Tailings is the more unique, one of a kind experience. However, I rated City Park half a disc higher. Why? The Tailings is wild and unkempt, with tons of tee signs missing and a very rough feel. Despite being an incredible course, it needs some TLC. By comparison, City Park is very well maintained, with all the signage intact, better baskets, good navigational aids, etc. You can tell this course has been taken care of.
City Park is pretty heavily wooded for most of the course, with some truly spectacular elevated shots including 1 and 15. Hole 1 has nice built in stairs; 15 could use the same treatment, as it is a very steep descent. This course is actually quite short for 18 holes at around 4500 feet. I played this course in just over an hour solo never having played it before. I didn't feel like I was rushing, and I had a great time and a good challenge. Despite all the up and down trekking, the course plays pretty quick.
The course is technically challenging to make up for the short distances, but fair. It felt like there were a lot of doglegs and an emphasis was placed on hitting your fade/turn at the right place on the fairway to get that perfect line. For a wooded course, the rough here was very reasonable. It made the course play quickly and pleasantly not having to constantly hunt for discs.
This course may be just a slight stretch to award a 4; it's probably about a 3.75, and most reviews seem to come down on one side of that or the other. Overall, it was in great shape and I found it really enjoyable and exactly the type of hilly, wooded course I visited the UP for. If you like coffee, there are also some nice independent coffee shops in Iron Mountain. A visit to the Iron Mountain/Florence/Iron River corridor for disc golf is highly recommended and this should be a stop for everyone.