Pros:
For the most part, awesome holes. Number 1 is a bit bland, but 2 is a visually impressive touch shot down to a kinda naturally raised basket with a stream cutting some elevation into the fairway and woods to either side. From 4 onward until you come back to the woods on 17, it's all beautiful park golf, but still fairly technical on most holes. Number 10 is a spacious 700 foot par 4 with a fairway defined by the sidewalk left and the river right. Looks like it wandered off a ball golf course. Holes 15 and 16 are big long bombs with reasonably well-defined, not too wide lines to make through the trees. Holes 17 and 18 have to be one of the more punishing finishes I've played. I thought I was home free at that point, in for a glorified walk back to my car, and would get out a few over. Then I got to 17, a classic technical par 4 with a reasonably small landing zone and then two tight lines at the basket. 18 follows it up with a 325'-350' dead straight downhill tunnel that finally breaks back out into the open for the last 150' or so of hole. Total length is over 6000 feet, with only a couple holes approaching what I would call open; all but holes 1 and 10 offered a fair amount of restriction, and even those had some tree cover off to the sides - plus a lil river on hole 10.
Two holes have two pin positions, fifteen have three, and one has four. They seem to change up some every time I visit, so that makes for great variety.
Baskets are Mach Vs which have held up quite well. All the long tees are reasonably sized concrete trapezoids or rectangles, except hole 6 (turf in good shape, which is good enough for a shorter hole). Brand new tee signs are in the ground, and accurately represent the various pin positions, trees/rough, OB areas (water/roads/sidewalk), etc. They indicate distance and par as well. There are benches throughout - not every hole, but probably about half the holes, and all the ones likely to cause backups - smart. There are bag stands on most as well, and nice new wooden bridges over creeks/spots that could get feet wet. Back at the start, there's a community board and a practice basket.
Very pretty parkland, but the truly killer view from the banks of the Cahaba can be found by going down the stone steps next to hole 10's pad (or the set by the right-hand pin on 11).
Cons:
A couple pads are cracked, but nothing bad at all. Of the am pads, only two were concrete, and all others were, to my knowledge (didn't try to play them) natural or nonexistent; the natural ones have a little, low, hard to find marker.
The big sidewalk (greenway?) that keeps coming into play is a bit troublesome, but there's visibility more than far enough for a sensible, safe disc golfer to simply wait to throw until nobody is in harm's way. Do that.
Other Thoughts:
This course could get a bit nicer yet with some concrete for the am pads, or a few permanent next tee signs, but it's already been completely transformed over the past year from a closed-off construction site to one of the best courses in the state, thanks to a committed group of locals. Even over the past two to three months, the glow-up has been huge. The course will also do some growing on its own now, as there are new trees strategically planted on 1, 10, and maybe one or two other holes.
As far as metro Bham courses I've played, this one ranks second, edging out Clay but falling to Inverness.