Pros:
- owners are great, accommodating people
- some excellent incorporation of elevation change
- beautiful mountain views
- course is pristine and very well maintained
- equipment is generally in good condition
- front 9 is heavily wooded and very technically challenging
- long holes and generally quite difficult, but fair
- some flags on poles above baskets for help with blind tee shots
- some next tee arrows on baskets, but not many
- some good amenities such as ice for sale, port o potties
- good incorporation of creek hazard from 14 onwards
- pond hazard on hole 1 and again later in course
- some nice built-in bridges across creek
- rough is generally very forgiving in woods; easy to find discs
Cons:
- turf tees and Mach 3 baskets are just ok
- some tee pads are sloped which is not great for power/ankles
- navigation was confusing at times
- temporary tee signs only for WV Open; typically no real signs
- some baskets have missing or incorrect hole numbers
- hole 15's fairway is unrealistically tight
Other Thoughts:
Where to begin... I almost can't believe I actually have visited Paw Paw, WV and have played the legendary Woodshed. This has probably been on my Wishlist for 10 years as one of those "well, maybe someday next to never" courses. Two years ago I started traveling just to play disc golf and here we are. It's a trek out to this property, as others have mentioned. The drive is actually really cool, provided you have some patience - and 4 wheel drive doesn't hurt, though it wasn't really necessary on the day I visited.
The owners were extremely friendly and I am very envious of the amount of land they have and so grateful they open it up to the disc golf community. $10 to play is more than reasonable for the staggering amount of maintenance it must take to maintain these two courses. Ice is available for $5, and sure that's a little on the higher side for a bag of ice, but you really are in the middle of nowhere, and I was extremely glad they offered this. I didn't really meet Spencer, but his wife (Gabby, I believe) was very kind and gave me a map to help with navigation. The owners are not as young as they once were but the courses still look impeccable. Make sure when parking you do not block the gravel roads, as the owners have neighbors who have to drive through their property to access theirs. I was told parking on the grass was fine. It's unclear to me if the port o potties are a permanent fixture or just were there from the tournament, but it's nice to have a bathroom option - there is nowhere you can stop nearby.
For courses of this caliber, the equipment was a bit surprising. The turf teepads are just ok, and the Mach 3 baskets work fine, but are the typical "haven't been updated in 20 years" course baskets. The real issue is the tee signs, which were temporary and fine when I was there, because I lucked out playing near the WV Open. At other times, I'm not sure if they have any at all, and navigation was already a bit confusing for me; I imagine at other times it may be pretty tricky. All that said, it is well worth the drive out here to play these courses despite these issues.
When I arrived around 7 AM, I was the only person here, which was cool. I got to enjoy the West Virginia solitude in the rolling hills and just listen to nature. I was surprised that when I left about 4 hours later (after playing both courses), I was STILL the only one on the course. This was a Friday morning, but I'm amazed the owners can keep this course going considering in half a day they brought in $15 from me - and that appears to be it. It's not exactly a convenient area to get to, but please consider making the trip to ensure we can enjoy this course for years to come.
The water hazards at Woodshed are neat, with a small pond forcing careful shot selection on hole 1, followed by a creek hazard in the thick of the woods later in the round. Holes 3-7 are pretty deep in the woods, and the course wraps around back into the woods on hole 14, emerging later for the end. While the wooded fairways are tight and very challenging, I felt they were all fair except for 15, which has so many trees and no real discernable fairway it starts to feel like more of a luck shot. The terrain on these wooded holes will wear you out, and I recommend some boots with ankle support. After the Woodshed, I guess it was only appropriate I headed over to Whippin' Post for some more punishment.
While I was near hole 15 or 16, a dying tree collapsed in the woods maybe 50 feet from me. For all the fallen trees I've seen disc golfing, I've never actually seen it happen. Sure gives you a bit of a heart attack until you realize you're out of harm's way! Wrapping up the course on hole 18, the barn forces a bit of a mando shot to the basket between it and the road, which makes an otherwise open shot fairly challenging. A lot of the holes at Woodshed are very long par 4s and a couple of par 5s; you will get a workout and an intense challenge.
Overall, I struggled to rate this course. I would like to place it around a 4.25. Compared to some of the great 4.5s I've played, I think the so-so equipment and confusing navigation held this one back a bit. It is a fantastic challenge and is on the more unique side in terms of setting and natural beauty, so the 4 feels a bit unfair, but that's where I came down. I had a great time and encourage anyone to visit - just prepare for some punishment!