Ya, I have played Turtle Rock a bunch and there are a ton of locations for each hole allowing for many different feels on that course. I will agree that the water that is available at BOP is a huge plus, and something that Trock can't provide. The camping is average at best and you really luck out if you find a spot that isn't rocky, but it is possible. I didn't really consider that an amenity though at trock in my review (even if I mentioned it). There are simply much better places to camp there in the area for free.
So yes we will have to agree to disagree on this matter.
That being said, if you find yourself at any of the three mentioned courses you are pretty fortunate, and could do much much worse.
I live in Arcata, downtown, and would be up to grab a beer sometime or play a round if you are interested.