Originally Posted by dscmn
What about just adding "clearly" to each of the above parts of the rule?
I'm thinking this would effectively put the onus on the jump putter (where I believe it belongs) to perform the putt in such a way that makes it completely and obviously legal to his card mates. The grey area putts would become stance violations. If it's too close to call, it's a stance violation.
I agree with everything, except for maybe the calling your shot part. I think I'd get sick of hearing someone go "I'm going to jump putt" and having to respond "I already know you suck the fun out of the sport."