Just give me some signs!
2 Helpful / 0 Not
Pros: - Challenging course from the longs.
- Really fun course from the shorts.
- Nicely constructed concrete tee pads.
- The layout does not seem to favor either righties or lefties.
- Brilliant pin placement on many holes. #17, #10, #8, #2, #14 are a few that come to mind.
- I love the use of water on #14 on both the long and short tees.
- Not really a pro or a con but the elevated basket on #9 is nicely done compared to some I've seen. At the same time there doesn't seem to add much of a challenge to the hole.
- Not a lot of elevation change here but what is present is well used. #13 from the shorts is a great example. Trying to find a line between the trees up and over the hill there is challenging and fun.
Cons: - The course feels like it just isn't done yet. In particular #12 where there is some piles of dirt lining the sides of the fairway.
- Signs...where are they? There are a few arrows here and there indicating where the next tee is but that's it. No tee signs, no distances. If you are going to play here find a local to guide you around otherwise you're going to spend a lot of time hunting. There are 4x4's at each tee pad so it looks like signs will be installed soon hopefully. There are stakes at each tee with hole number but sorry, that won't help the score.
- More importantly there is a serious design flaw between #10 and #8 tee. Both the long and short tees for #8 are far too close to the #10 fairway.
- I am not particularly fond of how the #1 fairway is lined on the right side with a walking path that many non dg'ers use.
Other Thoughts: This has the potential to be a great course. Signage alone would help immensely.
I find this course to be a bit like jeckyl and hyde. On the shorts its a nice, pleasantly challenging round while the longs are a big step up in challenge. Stop by and play sometime - just be sure to bring a map.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful.
3 Helpful / 0 Not
Pros: Disc golf exclusive area, with no walking trails or other activities infringing on the course. New cement tee pads (both short and long) are outstanding, and are comparable to those at the best courses. Has the area's most exotic water holes on the back nine, with Hole 14 being the most dangerous example, with a 250-foot straight drive being necessary to avoid losing a disc. The long tee positions provide challenge even with Oshtemo's long tees. Hole 12 is a super long and challenging hole with an extended low-land fairway. Also has some good meadow holes, such as the Hudson Mills-style Hole 15.
Cons: One of the area's most flat courses, with Hole 12 being one of few examples offering elevation changes. Several tees require extensive backtracking after preceding holes. Signage is a bit lacking, and offers little clues to distance or basket location. Needs more benches and garbage cans on the course. Has several questionable design features, such as meadow holes with narrow tunnels bored into the woods to provide additional challenge (Holes 1, 2 and 9). Several woods holes are unfinished and have low cover that eats discs, with no redeeming features that make them fun. Holes 3 and 4 come a little too close to each other and can be difficult to navigate.
Other Thoughts: A worthy addition to the courses in the greater Kalamazoo area. Offers some open fairways for big drives, and favors those with big arms. Oddly, the bugs were not as bad as expected given the lowland surroundings. A free course with relatively low traffic for those sick of waiting around at Oshtemo.
3 of 3 people found this review helpful.
Worth the drive
3 Helpful / 0 Not
Pros: -Definite shot variation here. Classic Knollwood sidearm bros would not succeed; you need to have multiple shots in your arsenal to score well.
-Open shots and wooded shots galore. Variety is beautiful
-Risk v Reward (as others have touched on): very prevalent here, but not in a "mean" way. Water in play on ~4-5 holes.
-Distance variation is superb here. Power drives followed by powered down drives occur multiple times.
-Love the pin placement. I think it's in the best possible spot on almost every hole. Obviously designed by somebody who knows disc golf well.
-Pro tees offer true challenge. Both tees offer challenge and fun. The way it should be.
-New baskets that shine in the sun. Glorious.
-Practice baskets right off to the side of the parking lot
-Uniqueness is here, particularly the hole with the basket behind the mound of dirt. Nice touch.
~May '13 Concrete Teepads are ready to go!
Cons: -Permanent signage would really be a plus (on both teepads would be a double plus)
-Elevation is really pretty average here. Not non-existant, but not enough to be a true factor
-Rough is a bit "rough" in spots. Time will fix this.
Other Thoughts: Not a whole lot of downside here to speak of. For me, a lack of elevation would stop this course from ever achieving a 5-disc rating, even if it was kept as well as The Masters golf course in Augusta. Tee pads and permanent signage would land this in the 4.25-4.75 range easily, but not a true "5".
That being said, this is a really fantastic layout. Pro tees would offer a real challenging tournament setting even for top pros. I love the intelligent design and design execution. Truly, those who live in the SW michigan area are DGCourse-spoiled (myself included). This course adds to that fact. GO PLAY!
3 of 3 people found this review helpful.
Tasty Water Hazards. Solid.
6 Helpful / 0 Not
Pros: - Vicksburg Rec. Area (VRA) deftly combines water hazards, woods, scrubby undergrowth, and grassy open areas to create a challenging but accessible 18-hole course suitable for a broad array of skill levels. Long tees (marked red) offer challenging lines and some significant distance for more advanced players while the shorts (white) still pack a punch in places, with trees, water, and scrub still waiting to ruin a round.
- Good use of limited elevation. Two holes (#'s 6 and 14 each have an earthen bump with a crop of trees on top in front of the basket. Several holes have slopes down into water near the basket (#3, 7, 10, 14, and 17). #'s 12 and 13's gradually sloping fairways make good use of minimal but effective elevation.
- Great use of the water. Several basket placements will more often than not leave you putting with water directly behind the pin (#'s 3, 7, 10, 14, and 17). A cute tiny little island sits in the middle of the pond on #16. A fallen tree serves as a bridge out in case anyone lands on it. Long #14 has a reasonable water carry for RHBH hyzer and a bailout zone to the left. The earthen bump-with-trees protects the pin. What you can't see from the tee is that another pond lies directly behind the basket. Advanced players taking ace runs will lose anything long, and casual players could have any number of things go wrong.
- Good risk/reward. Go for those birdies or pars, but bang it home or go fishing on many holes. Other holes (#12 from the longs) encourage pushing the distance but wayward drives are punished brutally in the thick undergrowth off the fairway. Punishment is fair, but the schule can be a handful in a few spots.
- The flow is intuitive and straightforward. Each tee is marked with a stick labeled with the hole number. Long tees are painted red and shorts are white. Practice baskets labeled #'s 19 and 20 are located near #1 long's tee.
- #18 offers a big annie or hyzer route through a patch of trees to the final basket.
Cons: - The biggest drawback is the natural tees. As of now, the tees are in okay condition; but with the amount of traffic a course of this quality will see, they'll be muddy rutted messes in no time. Already they are muddy and slippery in a few places. I assume a tee upgrade is in the works, as this is a newer course but well-deserving of concrete pads.
- Likewise, tee signage could use an upgrade.
- A few rough spots (the schule left of #12's fairway; the muddy walkway from #18 to the parking lot) could still use some clearing and maintenance (stuff that will come with time, undoubtedly).
Other Thoughts: - VRA is a solid discing option that only stands to improve with time.
- My rating reflects the state of the course on the date I played it (11/17/12) and takes into account the lack of proper tees. With a tee upgrade and a few more minor tweaks I see this course easily maturing into a 3.5-4 disc rating.
UPDATE: Concrete tees are installed (quite a while ago...sorry, forgot to update last time I was there). This course is settling in quite nicely, and I bumped it up .5 discs to reflect the positive changes.
6 of 6 people found this review helpful.
Join Disc Golf Course Review
for free to add your review. Have an account already? Sign In
to add a review.