Pros:
The Codorus State Park-Red Course is a beautiful compliment to its sister, the Blue Course. Played along the peaceful Lake Marburg, the Red course serves as a challenging, well-groomed park-style course for the first eleven holes and then quickly adjusts to deeply wooded fairways with fun lines.
The conditions of the course are excellent in the summer with grass mowed and rough trimmed back. Baskets are in excellent shape and all the tees are large cement pads.
The overall design is well done. A lot of elevation changes add variety and each hole plays just a bit differently from every other hole. The alignment has recently been changed from a 27 hole format (with 9 CC holes) to an 18-hole format, and I think the change is beneficial for the overall playability of the course. Hole lengths have been extended with the change and based upon what I have read in other reviews, the experience seems to have improved.
The variety of throws needed on this course makes for a hole lot of fun. With quite a few bomber-like holes, I could really stretch my arm. But there are many holes that require technical lines: straight, hyzer and anhyzer. I broke out my (mediocre) forehand on a few holes as well as some midranges on the drive in order to make corners. Beginner players beware, could be a long round.
Cons:
Obviously, for upper-tier courses, some amenities are expected: a decent map, descriptive sigs with detailed information about each hole, excellent flow to the design, easy traversability, and pin placements that make sense. This courses misses on these issues.
-The map is older and denotes the old design, before changes were made.
-The tee signs were nothing more than a post with the hole number, length and par listed.
-Though the first few holes flow well, the rest of the course does not seem to follow a "common sense" design. Having to backtrack to find some tees or walk great distances between holes is a regular problem with this course.
-It is not always clear how to get to the next hole from the end of the previous making traversability a challenge (of course, a ew map would help this greatly).
-Lastly, though I did like many of the interesting pin placements, with some in little glades, some near the water with excellent views of the lake, there were some pin placements that were strange. Hole 7 has an island hole (I am not a fan of arbitrary OB). Hole 10 is a 971 foot bomber with a basket down a hill next to the marina when it could have been placed up higher next to some trees, which would have been more accessible and with easier navigation to hole 11. Hole 14 puts a basket right behind some trees with very little opportunity to access the chains off the drive. Challenging? Yes. Niche-y? Also yes.
Other Thoughts:
Being that the first few holes are in a park near a lake, picnickers and other non-disc golfers are around. This means that players will have to wait at times and sometimes have to warn people of their throws. I played on a week day, so there were out many people around. Those that were there were nice enough to let me play through with little problem or waiting. But I could see that the weekends could be tough.
I could easily have given this course a 3.0 or even a 2.5 due to the need for standard amenities like an updated map and better signs, but I really had a lot of fun playing the course. And the "fun" factor overrules most other factors for me. Why else play this beautiful, frustrating game than to have fun, right?