Pros:
There a push for new courses to test the limits of players with longer layouts and more extreme challenges. Dolly Cooper reminds you that smart, creative designs are what ultimately make a solid course.
- This is a solid, well-thought out layout. Course has an excellent flow throughout where every 4-5 holes you seemingly get a mix of open & tight layouts, easy birdie chances and tougher, earn-your-par holes, from scenic layouts to not-so-much ones. The course offers about four of these hole clusters throughout the round, keeping things fresh.
- Scenic and isolated. The only other thing at the park as of this writing is a ball field (football/soccer). You're less than five minutes from a main, 4-lane road, but you might as well be 45 minutes out of town based on quiet and calm it is here.
- Course has an easy flow to it with the layout in the shape of a figure 8. The front nine is one loop on one side of the parking lot, and the back nine the other loop across the parking lot. Signage & navigation should be improved as the course gets better established.
- There are some instant classic hole layouts. The first is #5, an uphill, 330-footer that plays over the edge of a retention pond (?) to a protected landing area. From the tee, the only basket you see is #9, but #5 is shorter & left, slightly further into the woods. Challenging and scenic.
- #9 is a fun, short risk/reward layout. A downhill, 160-foot straight shot. The slope picks up and leads to a wide-open field just steps past the basket. An ace here is either a lucky bad-shot or a gutsy shot. If your shot is basket height and misses the basket, you could easily be looking at a second shot even longer than your tee shot. The smarter, yet still testy, throw is low and short, letting your disc hug the ground.
- The course ends on a high note, with #17 serving as one of the toughest tee shots. At 395-feet, the fairway narrows around the 275-foot mark, with a line of trees protecting short and right of the elevated tee. If you end up in this area, it's going to take great shot making to get a 3. A score of 2 on this hole, and on #2, is exceptional. Even getting a 3 requires a couple excellent shots.
- People are going to love or hate #18. It's a downhill 250-foot island green. It's a small island green. Personally, I think have solid OBs is better than the island green concept. Regardless, you'll probably throw a second disc here.
Cons:
The cons are most connected to new course issues: lack of signage, poor navigation, and a little more clearing needed. Throw in the general lack of amenities on the course, and you can see more work is needed for the course to reach its potential.
- Navigation needs improvement. I already mentioned the confusion about the basket on #5. Besides that, there are bike/walking trails that intersection with paths between holes.
- Also, I threw completely backwards on #15. You stand on the tee, you see the hole length is 150 feet, and you see a basket on a slight hill about the distance away. You then throw to it, finish the hole and then realize the tee immediately behind there is for #18. At that point, you conclude you probably just throw to basket #17, and accidentally skipped two holes. At least it was a short walk back. To be honest, #16 was probably the least memorable hole, a true 'filler' hole.
- Tee signage would help, especially on blind tee shots. I would have shot several strokes better if I knew where the baskets were located on multiple holes. I played the safe 250-foot straight down the middle tee shot on several of the blind holes.
- The biggest long-term issues are the long walks between the front and back 9s. Going from #9 to 10, you hole #1 and the basket for #18.
- It would be nicer to see one or two holes toughened to add a bit more spice to the layout. #10 for example could be a great, multi-shot par 4 if it were 100-150 feet longer. It looks tough from the tee but plays as a simple par 3 as it's an easy approach and putt.
Other Thoughts:
Dolly Cooper is a great addition to the Upstate disc golf scene. Just another solid course to play along the I-85 corridor.
- Copy & paste observation: course will get better with age. Navigation issues will be fixed. A branch or tree will be cut down, additional underbrush will be cleared out. Course will be broken in.
- I like the dichotomy of the front and back nine. Front nine is the 'wooded' half and back is the 'open' half. By that I mean the front side feels like you're in the woods, stepping out to play open holes. The back nine feels mostly open, with a few holes skirting up alongside the woods. Yes, both sides have a mixture of both. It's a feel thing.
- I'm surprised by how close you are to downtown and still feel like you're out in the country. Over the years, that isolated feel many disappear due to urban sprawl. In the meantime, enjoy this rural pocket.
- It'd be nice to find a way to better incorporate the Saluda River. There are some nice encounters - basket on #4, tee on #13 - but it'd be a nice touch to really get up close to the river. Perhaps push the tee on #13 a little further back.
- The course has one the best intangibles for me. The layout has a great flow & feel to it. From a simple warm-up hole on #1 to a tougher close to the round on #17 & 18 (especially if you incorporate the island green on #18), I love the ebb and flows throughout.
- With the split of the front and back, it also allows people to get in a quick 9, perhaps on a lunch break or right after work before the wife gets suspicious.
- Another excellent course in the Upstate. Fun and challenging throughout makes this worth a visit. Job well done!