Pros:
Course:
-Ability to start a round on holes 1, 5, or 10 without much walk from the 2 parking lots
-Single concrete tee with 2 baskets at each hole (newer DD Veterans usually short, old Mach IIIs in alternate positions) so players can choose their layout for the day and mix/match targets if they want.
-Favorite pins: 1E, 2D, 4D, 7C, 9E & F, 10C, 12C & D, 13B & D, 14D, 15D, 16B, 18C & D
-Longer pins are most interesting with some being very challenging par 3s. After getting the Veteran targets in 2020, these pins are in play more now with the second set of targets (old Mach IIIs). Set to the longest par 54 layout can make Rosedale a great challenge to string together a hot round (especially on windy days). Par 4 pins available on holes 4, 8, 16, and 18.
-Short pins can be a quick round (around an hour for solo/pair even with backups) or a good casual round for a mixed skill level group. Generally 1.5-2 hours maximum for 3-4 people.
-Elevation change is subtle on most holes with a lot of the front 9 having drop-offs to the right tree line going towards 'Down under'. Back 9 offers a bit more variety and hazards with OB roads and trees obstructing more of the left sides of fairways. Severe tree kick and roll away possibilities on 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 11, and 15 could leave players scrambling.
-Road in play/bordering fairway on 13, 14, and 17
-Veteran baskets get moved most weeks for league so playing Up Top can offer variety for locals and visitors from out of town.
-Risk of losing a disc is below average (except in Fall/Winter with the ground cover leaves/snow). With the amount of foot traffic & play Rosedale receives there is a decent chance discs will be found and returned to the lost disc return bin.
Park Amenities:
-Permanent bathrooms near skatepark by hole 1 and newly installed one near softball field by hole 10. Water fountain near hole 10 as well (used to be one near hole 1/tennis courts that got capped - maybe due to COVID precautions)
-Near KC city center, easy course to meetup at with access to/from I-35 at park entrance (Mission Rd)
Cons:
Navigation/Course flow issues:
-Navigation from hole 3->4 and 15->16 requires walking back up the fairway causing some slight backups
-Navigation from hole 5 left long pin to 6 tee, 11 long right back to 12's tee, and 13 longer tees near street corner back to 14's tee can all cause slight backups when they are being played
-Must cross street between 13/14 and back between 17/18.
-Some pins are missing from tee signs, no indication on tee sign which pins have targets in them.
Safety issues:
-Hole 8 and 12 tees in play from tee shots on hole 7 & 11. Windy conditions are common and new/unfamiliar players often do not realize how close their drives are flying towards those tees.
-Hole 5 pins in line with hole 6 fairway/tee shot, especially when playing hole 6 left pins.
-Some fairways are covered in broken up concrete/gravel (3, 5, 8, 9, 11, 14, 16), careful footing up and down hole 16, visible broken glass on 15 fairway
-Hole 10 tee shots towards pavilion and playground where park goers may be picnicking/playing. Sinkhole in fairway
-old pin locations are still around to cause tripping hazards
Course Layout
-Similar pin positions offer less variety on a few holes. Lack of shot variety especially when playing the short pins
-Some of the greens/landscaping/erosion control maintenance has been neglected. Baskets are mounted too low due to sinking/mulch accumulation around the pins.
-old Mach III practice basket is surrounded by concrete and doesn't match the DD Veterans that are primarily used for competition and casual players.
Other Thoughts:
Rosedale park has a long history being used in many Kansas City Wide Open tournaments and various events throughout the years. Many of the KC club members have offered up time to maintain and keep the course accessible to the community and players of all skill levels.
-Rosedale Up Top underwent a redesign around 2015 which altered the flow on a number of holes and added current hole 10 and 16. No longer playing alongside backyards for 16 & 17.
-Busy after work/school hours (4pm-sunset) and on weekends midday through the evening.
-Leagues on multiple weeknights during the summer, glow league later in the year (park doesn't close after dark).
-High level of traffic means the park requires a lot of maintenance/upkeep. Some holes with erosion/soil control problems. Attempts to grow new trees in open fairways have had limited success.
-Rain brings long grass and mud to some of the low-lying fairways (4, 5, 10, 11, 14)
-2 courses in the same park offer a good variety of park/wooded golf
-Shared multi-use park with pavilion/picnic tables, playground, skatepark, tennis courts, 1 fenced baseball/softball field & 1 open baseball/softball/soccer field (useful for fieldwork), and trails joined up to the Rosedale trail system (many dog walkers). This can make parking a challenge during different parts of the year.
-Dynamic Discs KC store up the street where lost discs return bin goes (2-3 month holding then donated)