McDonough, GA

Salem Baptist Church

Permanent course
2.925(based on 6 reviews)
Filter course reviews

Filter reviews

Filter reviews

Salem Baptist Church reviews

Filter
11 0
Shadrach3
Gold level trusted reviewer
Experience: 6.2 years 339 played 325 reviews
2.00 star(s)

Haphazard, but Enjoyable 2+ years

Reviewed: Played on:Dec 22, 2020 Played the course:once

Pros:

A piecemeal course with several different personalities that offers a reasonably enjoyable round.

-Amenities: Everything you need. Middle-of-the-line tees, baskets, and signage.

-Variety: Kind of impressive for a church course. Some long open holes, some shorter woods holes, in-between density, and a couple of weird little holes by the ball fields. This feels like a real rec-level course, not a pitch 'n' putt just tossed in a back yard.

-Multi-Shot Holes: Five for nine on par-4 or higher is an impressive feat. It's fun, too.

-Shot Shaping/Gameplay: Generally pretty decent. The first three are longer open holes for routine driving. The next two are quirky holes that have you throwing your approach to the basket very awkwardly to avoid baseball fields. A par-2 then leads to the more wooded close of the course, which once again requires pretty solid play to score well on. I would peg the difficulty at higher rec-level. Without a decent drive it's hard to do well, and the woods holes are trouble if you aren't smart, but if you can throw controlled in the upper 200s then you have nothing to worry about. The basic idea of most of these holes is good--see cons for why it doesn't rate higher.

Cons:

-Hole Design: Almost every hole out here seems to have at least one major flaw, excepting (9). The opening holes are just too open--not a big deal. The baseball field holes are really strange. (4) is tight off the tee, but doesn't make clear where you should land for the really tough approach to a basket sandwiched deep between two ball fields. (5) has a bad mando. (6) is a par-2, so boring. On (7), it's very difficult to tell where you should throw off the tee for a blind basket. (8) has a ridiculously pinched angle off the tee, which was very poorly placed. There is no characteristic flaw out here, but with so many little things it really detracts from the experience.

-End Point: Course ends at least a quarter of a mile from the parking, if not more.

-Safety: The ball field holes could obviously be problematic during games. Also, (7) and (8) play with walking paths, so that could be an issue at times.

Other Thoughts:

There are relatively few things to say about Salem Baptist. It's a basic kind of course. The environment and length out here gives it the potential to be a really good 9-holer with a 3.0 rating, but a series of unfortunate choices limit the actual enjoyment of the holes so much so that I consider it only "Reasonable." I hope someone can make a few tweaks to this course and let it see its best possible version.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
10 0
Cerealman
Diamond level trusted reviewer
Premium Member
Experience: 16.4 years 665 played 192 reviews
2.00 star(s)

Decent distance but drab design 2+ years

Reviewed: Played on:Jun 26, 2020 Played the course:once

Pros:

South of Atlanta and several miles off of Interstate 75, the Salem Baptist Church offers a 100-acre-plus campus, complete with a park, walking paths and recreation fields.

Oh yes, and a nine-hole disc golf course.

But at nearly 3,200 feet, the Salem Baptist Church DGC is no dinky disc golf course.

The first two holes are wide open and bridge the walk from the parking lot to the rest of the course. However, these holes are ideal for warming up. Hole #1 is 587 feet and involves throwing down a hill and across a large grassy field.

The course beauty is good and improves along the way, as the last two holes are the prettiest on the course.

Navigation is easy, as the next teepad is easily spotted from the previous basket.

Cons:

The walk from Hole #9 back to the parking lot is about one-third of a mile. There is a small path through the woods so you don't have to retrace your steps, but it's still a short hike.

Hole #6 is listed as a par-2. Granted, at only 140 feet, it isn't too difficult, but there are several trees in the fairway that can interfere with the path to the basket. According to the PDGA guidelines, "Designing Par 2 holes is not recommended." There is room for the basket to be moved; extending this hole even 40 or 50 feet would merit a par-3 rating.

And while we're nitpicking about par, a few other holes might be questioned. Hole #2 is 415 feet but wide open and finishes slightly downhill. Hole #4 is 473 feet but listed as a par 5. Hole #8 is 350 feet and downhill; even with the tight line, a par-4 rating seems slightly generous. And Hole #9 is 390 feet but fairly open. All three of the par-4 holes feel like "tweeners." The overall par for the course is 32, but a par of 29 or 30 seems more appropriate.

Holes #4 and #5 play near the fenced baseball fields and use the tall, yellow foul poles as mandos. While the course designers wanted to discourage throwing over the corner of the fenced outfield, the design is poor and gimmicky. This design flaw is easily fixable by moving the basket for Hole #4 and the teepad for Hole #5. And if there are individuals using the fields, playing these holes might not be safe.

There are signs at every teepad, but they've been susceptible to wear and bird droppings.

The teepad for Hole #8 is pointlessly placed behind a couple large trees and limits one's options. This teepad should have been moved 10 to 25 feet to the left. Or get out the chainsaw.

Other Thoughts:

I was skeptical of the 3.38 rating for a nine-hole course, and my suspicions were confirmed. While the distance might boost the appeal and provide more disc golf than the typical pitch-and-putt church course, the course does not merit such a lofty rating. Especially considering that a majority of the holes are dull or daft in design. The first three holes are wide open. The fourth and fifth holes are weirdly designed around mando foul poles. The sixth hole is a filler par-2. Only the last three holes can meet the standard of good disc golf holes.

Until a few holes are redesigned, Salem Baptist Church falls into the "reasonable" category.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
1 0
Lewis Roberts
Experience: 1 played 1 reviews
3.00 star(s)

Fun little 9 holes 2+ years drive by

Reviewed: Played on:Jan 17, 2020 Played the course:5+ times

Pros:

New concrete tee pads.
Easy to navigate.
Good mix of shots.

Cons:

If ball fields are being used there can be cars near one or two holes.
Short. (Hole 6 is a par 2, 140ft.!!!)
Long walk from hole 9 back to parking lot.
(Hopefully 9 more holes will be in the future!)

Other Thoughts:

Just a fun little church course that offers a few opened holes then some wooded holes to mix things up. Lots of potential for the future. Good for beginners as there's not a whole lot of trouble to get into.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
8 0
DumfriesLizzie
Gold level trusted reviewer
Experience: 6.2 years 119 played 102 reviews
4.00 star(s)

Best 9-hole course to date 2+ years

Reviewed: Updated: Played on:Dec 26, 2019 Played the course:once

Pros:

Best 9-hole course I've played to date. Very good-looking, well-maintained course.

Though initially intimidated, starting with two long holes is a good idea: rip it early and get that out of your system.

Thereafter, you've got to play with strategy versus abandon: avoiding OB along left fairway (no. 3), uphill with mando dogleg (no. 4), downhill with mando dogleg (no. 5), into or in the woods (nos. 6-8) that get tighter and longer, out of a grove of trees into a wide-open green (no. 9).

Long tee pads with decorative, swirl pattern in relief. New tee pad signs with perfect information.

I don't mind the footbridge from 9 to 2. Just be aware of any players on 1 & 2.

Cons:

Current construction in no. 1 fairway makes it muddy.

Thorny bushes in deep rough, and anthills all over. Will be a real danger in warm months. If your disc lands on an anthill, the ants will get on it and bite you later. Be aware, check and wipe your discs.

Other Thoughts:

I love this course. Will play it often when visiting GA. I hope it stays around. In a park with baseball fields, walking paths, a pond, open fields (for soccer, football, etc.), picnic shelters, etc. On private church land. Church asking for donations to continue.

Play two discs to play 18 holes. By playing holes twice, you will learn the course faster and improve on this course (any 9-hole course) quicker. Which is very encouraging.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
5 0
lazrman778
Gold level trusted reviewer
Experience: 13.8 years 264 played 100 reviews
3.50 star(s)

Salem Baptist Church 2+ years

Reviewed: Played on:Jul 23, 2016 Played the course:2-4 times

Pros:

Has tee signs

Natural tees were flat and fair to drive from

Good mix of open/wooded fairways with doglegs, mandos, and elevations

Had whole course to myself on a Saturday evening

Easy to navigate

Well-maintained

Free parking at multiple locations

Porta potty

Cons:

Long walk from hole #9 basket to parking lot

Nasty overgrowth along stream on hole #1 fairway

Other Thoughts:

This is a nice addition to the Henry County area that serves as a good warm-up for nearby JP Moseley Park. This course is pretty impressive for a 9 hole course on church property. Some of the pars may be little on the soft side but should be perfect for the rec player. Nice variation in pars, elevations, fairways, and mandos should make this fun to play. I like shooting around the mando poles on holes 4&5 as that adds some difficulty to the course. I'm not sure about the box truck on hole #7 but it doesn't seem to have moved since the pic was taken years ago. There's a lot of land here to make it 18 holes but it's pretty good as it is for a quick round.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
6 0
Duncanator
Experience: 14.6 years 216 played 13 reviews
3.00 star(s)

Not your average church/9hole course 2+ years

Reviewed: Played on:Feb 20, 2014 Played the course:once

Pros:

Nice brand new baskets.
Some good length to this course, 400s, 500s, uphills, downhills. A good mix of straight, lefts, and rights playing the OBs around the ball fields. Open in the front leads to some wood holes in the back 4 holes.
The course puts you away from the main walking area, avoiding pedestrians nicely.
Good signs on each hole.
Generally good flow between holes.

Cons:

Biggest problem is that hole 9 leaves off away from anything. To get back to your car, you need to walk through the path in the woods and then back the entire length of hole 2 and hole 1.
Without an over all course map, finding a couple of the tees can be a little tricky (hole 6 is in the woods if you follow along the ball field fence & hole 7 is further up the path towards the house)

Other Thoughts:

Good local course to get out on.

Park in the gravel lot after turning at the light. Go straight through the gate down the car path towards the white sign and the single tree for hole 1.

Doesn't play around the church building, but around the park beside the church (church property?)

Certainly a fun course, much better than excepted for a 9hole church course.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
Top