Pros:
The Tracks, though only months old, is already a pleasant course with clean and interesting lines.
-Amenities: Multiple practice baskets, concrete tees, brand new DISCatchers, excellent next tee signage, and even a lost disc box. No course map, but it was so well-marked that I never needed one.
-Ambience: The Tracks plays through a very nice tract of woods, next to a rail line and working around a trail (no pedestrian risk). It's a great feeling to throw through a forest, and the course only makes it better with appropriate logs marking the fairways and very tasteful (if not particularly helpful) tee signs. It's also fun to hear a train come past during the middle of your round.
-Clearing: I'm very impressed at how clear the fairways already are. There's a little more work to be done, but mostly the fairways are ideal in terms of skippy-ness and grippy-ness for woods play, both on the wider and the tighter holes.
-Shot Shaping/Gameplay: I can't think of a single boring hole. Doglegs left and right, flex lines, huge curling holes, straight shots, tight gaps, gentle curves, placement shots, split fairways, par 4s and 5s, breathable and tight fairways, ups and downs--the Tracks has all of them. For example, within the first 4 holes I had to make a lay-up/go-for-it decision, execute a placement shot, throw a perfect flex, and attempt a woods par 5. There are some very difficult shots out here that will have a player of any level feeling satisfied, and you have to pick a line on every hole.
-Difficulty: I think the Tracks will be an upper intermediate or advanced challenge. After the first eight holes I was thinking that it didn't seem too tough, but then the trees closed in and the overall course difficulty shot up.
-Multi-Tees/Pins: Several holes have different tee and pin options, but it's not really a big pro. I didn't know whether or not each hole had a short tee until I walked past it (the only flaw in the otherwise amazing next tee signage). Also, the second pin placements in many cases weren't different enough to warrant their existence.
Cons:
The course can't entirely hide its newness, and at times feels repetitive.
-Youth-Related Cons: The most obvious is the tee signage. The Tracks deserves a thorough map on each tee. Secondly, the fairways, while good, are not perfect yet. There are some random clumps of vegetation that shouldn't be there, a stump here and there, and there hasn't been time for a good layer of pine straw and natural debris to smooth over the mud yet.
-Repetition: Once you get most of the way into your round, some of the hole designs feel a little familiar. There are several holes that curl back more sharply than a dogleg, and I became bored of them. Also, the back nine feels like it has a lot of holes that begin with a very straight and tight fairway, and then several hundred feet down have a small pocket to the left or right. These are good hole designs that every course needs, but somehow the Tracks just crams too many similar ones in. I loved the first seven holes or so, and (16)-(18) were a good finish, but in between I was getting tired of the same two kinds of shots.
-Monothematic: The Tracks is entirely wooded. Only (16) could be considered open, and that's a short hole. There are some slightly more breathable holes, but it's essentially one biome throughout. You have to be virtually perfect to get an Excellent for a course without much terrain variety.
-Choice: There isn't much flexibility at all in terms of shot choice in between the tight fairways and no intentional design for multiple flight paths. Small con only.
-Not Beginner Friendly: Maybe the first seven holes would be okay. After that, way too difficult to hit the fairway or scramble for anyone less than a determined rec player.
Other Thoughts:
As so often happens in reviewing courses, I was torn between rating the Tracks as "Very Good" or "Excellent." I settled for the former mainly due to the first two cons listed. I really enjoyed my round at the Tracks. For those familiar with Little Mulberry, the Tracks feels like that but not yet polished and a touch harder. With a little bit of wearing in and signage, the course could become Excellent. I slightly overstated its status in my original review, but even if not a Top 3 in Atlanta, it's still an asset to the metro area.