Is there a consensus on the most overstable P2's between S-Line, G-Line, C-Line, and Color Glow? And to make it more interesting...the new swirl McBeth P2s? I might assume they are all so close, but curious to know if there is in fact a difference.

Color glow and C line seem identical to me. G-P2 a hair less but also similar. I would call all of them stable, in that they have loads of HSS but not too much LSS, only reliable medium/light fade.

Truly OS putters are a whole other thing. And I am not ragging on P2s, love them and they are versatile discs, moreso than utility OS putters, which are just in another league.

Any chance for bottom stamped DM discs?

That answers it. And yeah, I know what you mean. I meant OS relative to P2s of different plastics. I'm looking for a P2 that keeps its fade for a long time. I find them OS enough.

Any idea when the d-line P2 restock will come?

The current run of S-line are REALLY overstable for some reason.

Echo is the sweet spot IMO. I think they fly like a DD2 should.

S-Line > G/C/Glow

1st Run S-Line (flat yellow or orange w/mcbeth stamp) > Swirly

Ok thanks! And I actually meant to ask my question quite literally, waht is echo star? haha

ahh, it is recycled star plastic.

I just got my 2 5th run fD's :O they feel perfect in the hand I need to throw them! max weight

Wait, you mean to say S-P2 is more OS than C? Or am I misunderstanding your equation?