DGPT All-Star Weekend 2021

[Jay Dub]

Even KC himself has said Paul is a better player than he was

*fingers in ears*

NANANANANANANA!!!!

[ToddL]

Originally Posted by _MTL_

McBeth is the best player of all time.
Climo is the most dominate.

There's a difference.

Dominant.

[Nick Pacific]

Originally Posted by _MTL_

You are using results to judge who is better. That's not a representation of who was better rather who was more dominate. The two things are loosely related but not the same thing.

Even KC himself has said Paul is a better player than he was.

So results and accomplishments don't matter and we are judging purely based on disc golf skills? Then by that metric Eagle McMahon is better than both of them.

Better backhand, better forehand, better putter, roller, and pretty much every skill shot that you can account for

[_MTL_]

Originally Posted by Nick Pacific

So results and accomplishments don't matter and we are judging purely based on disc golf skills? Then by that metric Eagle McMahon is better than both of them.

Better backhand, better forehand, better putter, roller, and pretty much every skill shot that you can account for

Missing the point.

My point is I'm 955ish. Far from a top / elite player, but have decent skills. If my area has nothing by 800 rated players, I'm going to win left and right. That doesn't mean I'm the best player in the world.

Comparing players within the same era is easy - look at how they play against each other. You can't compare different eras quite as easily.