3 Helpful / 0 Not
Short, Clean Course
Pros: McClain, first and foremost, is well shaded, has clean fairways, and provides a great amount of shot variety for beginners and advanced players alike. Some of what I like
- Teepads- all concrete
- Teepad Variety- there are a few elevated and deep teepads for some holes, which I find adds to the challenge
- Shade- This would be a great course for a family or a big group looking to move slow, relax, huck and have fun
- Maintenance- Other than Hole #13, the whole course loops through the land really well and is very clean
- Access- it was very easy to find for someone that doesn't live in SATX. Also the parking lot has more than enough room to house vehicles.
- Technicality- despite being a bit shorter at times, many holes require some precise flight lines. Even the smaller holes can provide some trouble for this reason!
- Seating- I think there was a bench, placed rock or felled tree at every hole to relax while waiting or between throws at the teepads. Very nice!
Cons: - Signage- I got lost a couple times and some, so more signs directing to the next hole would be nice. Although there's a big map at the beginning of the course (which is a Plus) it'd be nice to have a better sense of direction. Same thing with teepad/hole info- there are a few holes missing this
- Length- Only 2 holes over 425ft, but many under 200ft or barely above. Not as much a con, per se, just would be nice to enhance variety (more than half of holes are 250-325ft)
Other Thoughts: This is absolutely a solid course- no drama, light challenge, good climate... That's about it though. For course standards it's just solid, but it doesn't offer anything that makes it stand out. That's OK! It just is what it is as a nice, easy course
I'd play this course regularly if I were in San Antonio as a nice quick round
3 of 3 people found this review helpful.
1 Helpful / 3 Not
McClain Park DG review
Pros: This review is coming from a Novice player who started playing back in November. I have played UC, Water bogged Schlater Park and Lost in the back nine Live Oak. This has been a great course to play on as it has its challenges. I like the difficulty to be just a little better that UC and it feels like a mix of UC and Live Oak. Has a little bit of everything which makes it fun. Will be playing this course more often.
Cons: This may be difficult to play if you've had recent rain. We saw a few places where the water was still standing and haven't had rain in a while. Nothing like Schlater Park though. Can be difficult to find the next hole as not great signage to tell you where to go, but found it easier to follow the path most worn would lead you to the next hole.
Other Thoughts: We GPS the directions the first time out and it told us to Park in a residential area and walk to our destination. This is not needed as you should be able to park in the School parking lot closest to the entrance gate to the park. If your new to playing disc golf this may be more of a challenge for you. Would recommend some of the other areas first before trying this one out as a beginner.
1 of 4 people found this review helpful.
1 Helpful / 2 Not
McClain Park DG Course
Pros: Nice variety of holes, McClain has wooded, open, & mixed terrain throughout the course you'll need to bring both your power & technical skills with you to play McClain.
I'm visiting San Antonio from Louisiana for work, the front 9 are backwards format at the present time. It was somewhat confusing figuring out where the tee pads and baskets were located. Everyone I have encountered has been extremely friendly and helpful, great DG community in SA.
Cons: Some hole tees and baskets hard to locate. Lots of Pokemon Go players walking around.
1 of 3 people found this review helpful.
1 Helpful / 3 Not
Pros: Nice variety of holes to play at Mcclain, trash cans on every hole, picnic tables on 7 long and 14, lots of shade, locals friendly, night golf almost every night, Mcclain disc golfers on Facebook to hook up with locals or others looking for a nice game or tour of park, monthly clean ups every last Sunday of the month till August
Cons: No water so bring your own, no bathrooms for the number of people that visit this course on a weekly basis but gas station close, not good to play if wet
Other Thoughts: A must play if your from out of town
1 of 4 people found this review helpful.
0 Helpful / 7 Not
Pros: Challenging course, but not too hard. Shaded, Clean, some very hard technical shots/holes. Overall great course.
Cons: Can't really think of any, Oh yea, Some hole signs are missing but thats really all the cons.
0 of 7 people found this review helpful.
10 Helpful / 1 Not
You Can Die Hard On A Couple Of Holes Here!
Pros: I don't know anything about this playing the course in reverse stuff. I think I played it forward. The course has concrete tee pads and yellow banded Discatcher baskets. The tee signs that are present give yu good information. This is a nice challenging course playing at a solid intermediate level. Better players will score well under par while us rec players can still enjoy the course and it's challenging side.
# 3 teepads was a nice bit of engineering. The hole is just 287' but the pad is raised and there is a gnarly tree with large branches forcing you to keep your drive low. I liked the looks of this hole a lot.
There are garbage cans and rustic branch benches here too.
Everyone mentions # 5 and # 6 and they both merit acolades as they really are memorable disc golf holes. # 5 is 405 with a dogleg right. The basket is then perched 20-25 feet up on a ledge and there is a swampy moat at the base of the cliffside. Fun hole! Not that incredibly difficult, just fun.
# 6 was actually freakier for me. It's just 140 foot almost completely over the swampy moat with lots of overhanging branches to knock your discs down It's probably a easy little forehand but for us players who don't have a forehand, it's a little tougher. Both of these holes would take on a different complexion after a rain with the moat/creek becoming engorged with flood waters.
I liked # 17 quite a bit with the basket perched just before the deep ditch.
The course ends back at the start which is always good.
Cons: I could see this course being a disaster after a rainstorm of any kind. The crreek alone could cause much havoc throughout the course. And i can see the mud being terribly slippery.
The back nine didn't quite measure up to the front nine, IMO.
Tee signs were missing on # 1, 9, 12, 13, and 17.
There was a garbage can at # 10 and it was overflowing. Who in charge of emtying these?
Other Thoughts: This is an delightful little course here. There were a couple of those signature holes that really stood out for me. Not too many clunkers. For being close to a couple of schools, the grafitti and vandalism was minimal. Middle school students are especially malicious little monsters around disc golf tee sins and baskets. I'd love to see those four missing tee signs replaced. It doesn't sound like this playing the course in reverse thing is real popular. I like the idea of A & B pads.
This is a nice solid course....Yippee-Ki-Yay mother*^%$^&^&#@!
10 of 11 people found this review helpful.
2 Helpful / 5 Not
Challenging and evolving course
Pros: I want to start by saying. This is my home course so I may be a little bias. I play here 3+ times per week.
That being said, at the moment the course is in McWrong (reverse) mode. It is a great change, both directions are a lot of fun. This course is the closest by far to my house and I love having to great courses in one location. The reverse mode is a little more of a position course, where placement is key, while in forward mode there are more shot options that open it up to big arm throwers that might not otherwise have as much control to handle the low straight shot that alot of the holes require in reverse. So the reverse kinda evens the playing field in my opinion. Both courses are alot of fun.
Cons: Need a map on the back of the current map that shows the reverse layout.
Other Thoughts: I can't give it a 5 bc there is always more work to be done to make it bigger and better.
2 of 7 people found this review helpful.
2 Helpful / 6 Not
Glad I took the time to play.
Pros: Nice mix of short, medium, and long shots. Short holes had a good risk/reward balance. You can go for the ace but if you mess up it is likely to be a hassle to get your par. Long shots were fair, not so hard as to keep novices from coming back, but difficult enough to keep advanced players coming back for the challenge. Beautiful course- a great representation of the beauty of the San Antonio area. This one my first time in San Antonio, if I go back, this will definitely be one of my stops.
Cons: Need for it's own parking lot. Schools shouldn't share their parking lot with strangers. One hole was a little confusing on the back nine, probably a work in progress.
2 of 8 people found this review helpful.
7 Helpful / 5 Not
Reverse McClain is Bad
Pros: This course has two layouts now, forwards and backwards. When the course is reversed (backwards) the baskets are near the forwards tee boxes and the tee boxes are near the forwards baskets. This is a review of the backwards layout.
This course has good baskets, an active group of people who keep it clean and in good repair, nice trees (for Texas on the back nine when in reverse), trash cans, park benches at the start and on the course, a little pavilion near the first hole, ample parking when the school isn't in session, a couple of weekly minis, an active Facebook page, night golf opportunities, and locals who are friendly and who will show you around.
Cons: The backwards layout has lots of problems.
There are greens where your disc can land within thirty feet of the basket and you will have no putt because of obstacles (This is true on reverse 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 13, 15, and 16.).
There are fairways without a clear path to the basket (Reverse 11, 15, and 16.).
There are holes that are well above the ability of the typical disc golfer the course sees (16 for example requires an absolute laser shot 300+ feet long through some tight spaces at the end to an elevated basket that is birdcaged by a bunch of little trees, utterly ridiculous).
There are a number of blind par 3's (2, 5, and 14). There is a table and benches beside the 14 basket. It's an accident waiting to happen.
The reverse course was designed to take away overhead shots from the tee when possible. This often results in a single shot choice from the tee, a low straight shot.
Other Thoughts: Forwards I would rate McClain a 4.0. Backwards I give it a .5. Since it is supposed to be reversed every other month (that was what I was told), I have to give McClain a 4.5 divided by 2 rating (a 2.0).
I'm worried McClain is going to end up like Live Oak when it's done being tinkered with. Live Oak does not have a set 18 holes that people play. There are 30+ holes and when people say they played Live Oak, you have no idea what holes they played.
Instead of reversing the course, I think more tee boxes and permanent alternate baskets should be added. If baskets are too expensive, put up tone poles until baskets can be bought.
Also, there is plenty of room for another 18 north of the current 18. Add those holes instead of messing up the ones that are there.
7 of 12 people found this review helpful.
2 Helpful / 6 Not
Well On It's Way
Pros: Long and short tees almost all the way around.
Great mix of technical woods and big open distance.
Excellent use of elevation and terrain changes.
Great signage and well maintained
Cons: Several pins only have one tee pad that really need a second one. Given how much harder some of the long pins are on the first half of the course, the lack of them on some of the easier, shorter pins in the back makes that section of the course a lot less challenging, comparatively.
Indicators on baskets of the direction of the next tee pad and indicators on the sign of which basket position is currently in operation would really speed up play, as well.
Other Thoughts: This would be a 4 or 4.5 review if the course had a full set of long tees, but more importantly, the change in the past year to the pin position of #8 is a serious problem. The pin is still only rated as a par 3 and yet the final 100 feet to the basket is (a) a more than 90 degree turn from the fairway (b) through a complete pinball machine of trees with no real fairway to speak of. Even left handed you have almost no hope of placing your drive anywhere that's actually helpful as your second shot _will be_ facing a wall of trees no matter where you put it.
The rule of thumb is that a fairway is something you can drive a small car through. While in theory you could drive a car from this tee pad to this basket, the last 100 feet would hardly be in what anyone would call a throwable line. They really need to either open up _some_ throwable line from the fairway to the basket or they need to make this a par 4. It is very frustrating to put a drive on a hole that technical about 40 feet from the pin and still end up with absolutely no chance at a bird because you can't even see the chains.
2 of 8 people found this review helpful.
Join Disc Golf Course Review
for free to add your review. Have an account already? Sign In
to add a review.