I have played Faylor and Agape Farm but not Muddy Run. Have seen Muddy Run on video here:Starting to iron out my October drive to see my folks in eastern PA. Will have time for one round per day on the drive up. The plan is to go from Fort Lauderdale to Rocky Mount, NC and stopping at Tom Triplett in Savannah. The drive will be finished Friday, leaving Rocky Mount and heading to Allentown. I'm really wanting to hit Faylor Lake, which is an hour from Harrisburg but well out of my way. The other option is Muddy Run, which is a lot closer to the travel route as it is south of Lancaster. Anybody here play both? I've seen Faylor on film twice, but never Muddy Run.
I would rate Faylor marginally better than Agape. The par 3's are better at Agape but the last few holes are not overly interesting. Both are absolutely great pieces of property with a lot of great holes. Both are also a ton of work to play with looong holes and big elevation. Both will be absolutely spectacular in October.