Pros:
An utterly beautiful plot of land with lots of good par-3 golf.
-Amenities: Concrete pads, DISCatchers, tee signs with only number, par, and distance, kiosk with map and such.
-Beauty: Phenomenal. Most of the course is in hilly, lush woods with plenty of older trees, but towards the end there are a few more open holes along the river, which is also nice. One of my favorite courses period if I were rating on natural surroundings.
-Elevation: Abundant. Some very steep holes, some more gentle ones, and some flat ones. A couple of valley holes are fun.
-Shot Shaping/Gameplay: A very enjoyable series of par-3s making good use of the land. Plenty of birdie opportunities, but also a couple of harder holes that will be a challenging 2. The front 11 are mostly very technical, mixing all sorts of shapes with multiple elevation scenarios. The end of the course opens up more, with a lot of medium-wide or field fairways leading to closed-off greens. Highlight holes for me include the par-4 (3), hole (4) leading over a valley with a cave mouth directly behind the basket, hole (13) shooting over a creek into the hilly woods, and hole (14) in the open with a gap and a creek crossing, but you'd get a different list from any other player. Overall, a lot of opportunities to throw a decently powerful shot that requires good touch to score the birdie.
-Atmosphere: Really a combination of all the above factors, because separated they don't do the course justice. Etowah is fun to play. It's relaxing and challenging, easygoing and rewarding. This is the kind of course whose flaws you're willing to overlook because it's a great time anyway.
Cons:
-Multi-Shot Holes: I think the biggest strike against Etowah is that it only has one true multi-shot hole. I think a great course should include a variety of off-the-tee decisions beyond "which disc will get me parked", and to exclude that level of variety keeps a course from reaching the circle of Excellence.
-Running out of Steam: Not a big con, but this is one of those courses that feels like it's just trying to get back to the parking lot after 14 or so. The holes aren't bad per se, but they're hardly striking and the least interesting part of the course.
-Signage: For a course as nice as Etowah, I'd like to see maps on the tee signs.
-Drainage: (1)-(5) had some problematic mud, and judging from other reviews they are often this way.
-Exertion: Be ready for a hilly workout.
Other Thoughts:
Etowah is a thoroughly enjoyable round of disc golf in an enchanting woods environment. Although the variety may not be top level, I'd recommend the course to anybody who wants a soothing stop on a trip, or just a place to chase birdies in the woods.