Pros:
- great elevation change
- great course diversity with 2 layouts in the same area
- some challenge added by water hazards
- good mix of technical and wooded holes
- excellent concrete tees
- great use of next tee signs for navigation
- generally nice baskets in good repair
Cons:
- tee signs are subpar for a course of this caliber
- this course clearly is perennially wet
- a few long walks during navigation
- bike path hazards
Other Thoughts:
I know I'm going to get some hate for saying so, but I pride myself on writing honest reviews: I think this course is overrated. I will caveat this by saying it is an excellent course, but at the time of writing this review it is rated a 4.61 (top in Illinois), and I just don't think it's quite that good. Without question, The Canyons is a higher caliber course and in my opinion is the best course in Illinois.
This course had a ton of upside, not the least of which is 2 (mostly) separate layouts which allow for a much shorter/easier layout and a much longer/more advanced layout. Very few courses I've seen have this sort of diversity. There is some excellent elevation change and a lot of cool wooded shots, while also including some more open shots. I especially liked how some of the wooded shots went downhill then back uphill, forcing you to deal with both types of elevation change.
The course was generally quite clean, appeared to be well maintained, and had nice concrete tee pads virtually everywhere. Although the parking lot was gravel, parking was ample, there was a main course sign with nice maps, and navigation was generally pretty easy. The extensive next tee signs were very helpful.
On the downside for this course, I'd point out the wetness factor and the tee signs. The tee signs were very basic and it was a surprising omission on an otherwise highly regarded course. They were fine, just not great.
Now for the wetness: I'll admit on the day I was here there a major snow thaw had just happened which exacerbated conditions. However, the course page on DGCourseReview recommends GoreTex shoes, so this obviously is an ongoing problem. There are a lot of low-lying areas that you can just tell are going to be frequently wet and muddy. I enjoy being outdoors as part of the experience of disc golf and I certainly don't mind getting a little dirty, but when I was playing I got absolutely trashed. My feet were soaking wet the whole game and there was standing water everywhere. I tried not to hold this against the course too much since I'm sure it was worse than usual on the day I played, and I'd rather have proximity to a creek like on this course than no water at all. Some of the muddy areas near baskets had some woodchips added but most could use some more help.
On a related note, there are definitely water hazards here where you can lose a disc. I enjoy the added challenge of this, and consider it more a pro than a con, but I suppose it depends on your perspective. I think this really adds to the diversity and appeal of the course.
It should also be noted the bike/walking path comes into play on some holes, which is not ideal. I think this only delayed me making a throw one time since it wasn't too busy the day I was there, but you do have to pay attention. Overall, this shouldn't be too big a deal.
All in all, with this course not being very close for me, I'm not sure when I'll be back. It's worth playing again, but I would go to The Canyons first in a heartbeat, which to me just has a bit more diversity and is a little more playable in all conditions. It's still an excellent course anyone passing through or in Northern IL should check out when they have the chance.