Pros:
Guilford Meadows is located right next to a small private college and is near a ton of excellent dining options in Greensboro. For most people in Greensboro, this is probably the course closest to them, and it can be a good spot to play a quick round after work or in the morning. It is not a championship-level course, but the design itself is well done, and the course could be (we will get to this later) an excellent course for beginners and for more experienced looking to practice tighter wood shots.
Variety: For a short course, Guilford Meadows still allows you to throw multiple different shot shapes and even has a few holes where players can open up. Very much a course where some holes are designed for backhand (4, 8, 13) while others are forehand friendly (2, 7, 14) and while the course doesn't have a ton of elevation, it does a good job mixing uphill (9, 15, 18) with downhill holes (2, 5, 11, 16).
Fun holes: Hole 1 is a relatively short tunnel shot to a basket with a drop-off behind it. 5 is a fun downhill shot that incorporates risk-reward where a player can choose to go for a two and risk going off the fairway into a pretty unforgiving forest or play it safe and card the easy three. Hole 7 is a relatively unique blind, over-the-top, right finishing shot. 16 is a medium-length downhill shot that allows for a more aggressive tee shot.
Cons:
Beginner unfriendly: The short length of most of the holes makes the course appear to be a beginner course, but it isn't because of maintenance issues. Getting off the fairway is harshly punished, and there is a high chance of losing discs on a lot of holes. Several holes are particularly good examples of this problem: 4, 9 (when not mowed). 15, 16 and 18. In the past, I have taken new players to the course and they have all been frustrated by the course. Obviously, that is anecdotal but it is a big problem for a course that seems designed with beginners in mind.
Maintenance: Whether or not the open holes are mowed is very hit or miss. Unlike other local courses, Guilford Meadows is often trashed (and there were signs up for a while threatening to pull the baskets, if people didn't pick up after themselves). Beyond these superficial issues, some of the holes need serious work. Some fallen trees need to be moved on 1, the overgrowth on 4 and 18 needs to be trimmed, the area around the tee pad on 7 needs work and hole 16 need some pruning. Unsurprisingly, these issues make it challenging to find discs, and the last couple of times I've played the course, I've found ticks instead.
Tee pads: The rubber tee pads are probably some of the worst that I have ever seen. They are a real slip risk when wet, and several should be completely replaced (7, 10 and 17 both come to mind). I don't usually care about tee pads, but these are dangerous.
Some bland holes: While most of the wooded holes are interesting in design, several holes blend together. 6 is a generic forehand hyzer, 9 is the classic, throw as far as you can in a field and have a short upshot for your birdie, hole. 11-12 are both short open field shots and 17 is a short generic hyzer. I don't hold the generic wooded holes against the design, but I think more could have been done with the field section to make those holes stand out.
Other Thoughts:
None of the local clubs hold events at Guilford Meadows, and the lack of care is reflected in the level of course upkeep. It seems like people, even those who play it, don't seem invested in the course, and it gets trashed more often than other courses in the Triad.
Still, the course itself can be quite enjoyable, especially in the winter, and the design is solid. This course could easily complement the red tees and patriot or the whites at Johnson for beginners if the issues with the tee pads and the rough were addressed.
I think the course could be a 2.5 or even a 3.0, but the issues I've addressed in the review limit it to being somewhere between 1.5 and 2.0. There are enough redeeming qualities that I decided to round up my 1.75 to 2.0.