Pros:
It's worth noting how close to the highway this is. If you are traveling down 40, it is only about a five-to-ten minute drive off the highway to get to this course. I found that rather appealing because it made it easy to play here spontaneously when driving from Raleigh to Charlotte.
The course features nice, even, concrete pads and new DISCatcher baskets. There are tee signs at every tee. The tee signs have nice, if not also somewhat funny at times, indicators letting you know where you are. Multiple holes have more than one tee, allowing players to choose fromIntermediate or Advanced+ layouts. Due to time constraints, I only really got to play the short layout. I walked the long tees and they all seemed to be really fun.
The course features a variety of wider, long holes and short technical holes. The fairways were all clear and required different shots to navigate well. The mixture of Par 4s and 5s throughout the round really made things more interesting.
I really enjoyed the subtle design choices that were used to make this course feel unique. Many of the greens were surrounded by large rocks which create a nice aesthetic and create decisions for golfers on what stance to use while putting. Other greens have death putt scenarios where there might be a creek or a pond behind the basket. Hole 10's green was extremely interesting with the pond so close to the basket, but the use of the root balls on the edge of the pond to help save runaway discs was very nice!
Despite being a newer course, you can tell this course gets a lot of traffic. The fairways are already beating in quite nicely, and despite playing it in the heat of summer the lines were still open enough for it to feel like a very established course.
Some tees have very tight gaps to hit off the tee shot, and that really spices things up and makes things interesting. Overall, the course felt like a decent player could score on any hole, or tank their round on any hole if they played it poorly. Many of the holes have multiple pin positions, when I played they were all in the A position, except for 18 which was in the B position, which should keep the course feeling fresh for locals.
One of the things this course did really well, was mixing up the elevation usage. Some tees played uphill, others downhill. Hole 17's basket was on the backside of a mound, which really spiced up the putting. Great variety overall in terms of elevation usage.
While the course doesn't shed water as quickly as some might like, it is clear that steps are being taken to try to alleviate that issue. Some concrete has been poured by a creek and gravel placed on a fairway to help prevent erosion. Not really the most aesthetic fixes, but at least the issue is being addressed.
Cons:
It's been said before, but I'll say it again. The lack of signage directing patrons of the park to the course is a huge oversight. I wandered around for quite a while before I found the course. It was almost hidden enough for me to just want to leave and play a different course since I was under a time constraint.
I didn't notice any benches on the course, which would give players a chance to sit and rest if needed. There also were no trash cans, but there wasn't any litter either (so for now that doesn't seem to be a huge issue). The tee signs would benefit from a map, because many of the baskets are blind from the tee. And by the time I reached Hole 10, I was tired of walking fairways to decide which shot to throw, so I am glad my drive didn't skip into the pond behind the basket. The direction signage could benefit from all being labeled Long/Short when there are multiple tees on the next hole. I saw it on one set of directional signage, but not all of them.
While I enjoyed the tight gap on Hole 9, the choice to have so many holes with tight gaps created by trees right next to the tees felt overused. I think the trees would also benefit from some sort of protection, Hole 9, which was the one instance of this I really enjoyed seeing, the two trees have already taken an incredible amount of abuse. If this is something that is to be preserved, it is important that the trees are protected by something like irrigation piping or something. Other times when this design choice was used the trees seemed almost dangerously close, where and errant drive could kick and hit a cardmate.
The rough on a few holes seemed abusively punishing, which is to be expected in the summer. Which is unfortunate since the course is located right in the middle of tick country. My biggest issue was how much rough encroached on the putting green for Hole 2. I was maybe ten feet (if that) from the basket, but my disc was in foot tall shrubs.
The course had a few tweener holes. Hole 6 definitely comes to mind when playing from the short tees, despite featuring otherwise excellent hole design. I turned my drive over a bit too soon and had to pitch out, and still managed to birdie.
Other Thoughts:
I am going to give Keeley Park a 3.5 rating for now. While I was torn on whether or not to knock it down an additional half-a-point for some of the cons I listed above (in particular the less than stellar signage and having one or two too many trees right in front of the tees), I felt bad giving a course with so many signature quality holes a lower rating. Overall, I think the design is really high quality, with excellent variety, and it seems to have been kept in good condition so far. Also, I figured the signage will get sorted out eventually anyway, since it is still a fairly new course.
The most frustrating thing about Keeley Park's disc golf course, is the fact that it didn't exist back when I lived in Greensboro. It is among the new wave of courses that has been built in the Triad the past couple of years, and it really elevates the level of courses you can find in that region. It is a great course that anyone traveling between the Raleigh and Charlotte areas should check out.
Favorite White Holes: 3, 6, 11, 17