Pros:
The course may not have been strictly finished when I played here, but that didn't really detract from my experience. Some of the holes had the tees and signs in: I can imagine that the rest of the holes will feature the same quality amenities. And with trusty(and fantastic) map in hand, I really didn't need the signs. Honestly, even in its unfinished state, I could have navigated this course without sign or map. The design is that intuitive.
I'm not sure what else will be done to Rock Ridge before it is considered finished. In my opinion, it doesn't need too much more work for me to list it as one of my favorites. Why? It's the curves. While this isn't the only course to feature established fairways,(as opposed to picking a line through trees) it is the on that has carved them at the perfect angle to be thrown down. The longer holes often feature two different curved sections. The first throw may be right to left, the second forces you to go back the other way. Here too, the angles are perfect for disc golf. If the first throw lands correctly, the second fairway will be just as beautiful as the first was off the tee. It's those damn curves, that get me every time.
Rock Ridge also brings a ton of variety to the table. There are short holes: six are under 200 feet. There are long holes: the two par fives are over 500 feet, long for wooded holes. There are holes of every length in-between. Ambitiously, the majority of the holes (excluding the shortest ones) feature multiple channels. Typically this means a right channel and a left, but 5, 14 and 6 feature three separate paths to the basket. Between the separate channels, and the two sets of tees, which do provide significantly different looks, there is a ton of replayability here.
There is also a ton of challenge. The par fours are real par fours. The par fives are indeed fives. I've yet to see wooded holes so long. They require not just accurate shots, but multiple accurate shots if you want to stay in the fairway. And if you want to score well, you need to stay in the fairway. In all it's one of the tougher courses I've played, and I like to think that the long tees, with multiple holes over 500 feet, and seventeen an impressive 741 feet down a wooded fairway, will challenge better players as much as the short tees do intermediates.
The flow is also impeccable. The paths between holes are a joy and transition from hole to hole seamlessly. There are a few next tee signs where the path joins the walking path, but most of the holes have absolutely no need of them.
In summation, it's just one of the best layouts that I've ever seen. I've never spent that much time thinking the curve of a fairway before. I'm sure it's rattled around in my brain on one course or another, but I've mainly noticed angles that were off. Here, I suddenly notice how all the curves are just right. But be careful, once you pass that threshold, you may not look at a different course the way that you used to.
Cons:
Well, there isn't any terrain variety. While the holes all play differently, the look is fairly consistent. There are also no open holes, and no water holes so if you want some of those, you are out of luck here.
It's also a bit of a haul between nine and ten. The route pops back out into the parking lot. This could be a pro for some, as it allows people to play nine, or twenty seven, or just start on 10. But leaving the course does break the atmosphere a tad.
UPDATE: If anything could be improved about the course, it's the drainage. Granted, this is just after an ice storm, but there has to be some way to keep water from sitting in tee areas. And a path should be constructed leading from the twelve basket to the thirteen tee.
Other Thoughts:
UPDATE: The above was written after I first played the course, when it was not yet complete. I had thought about waiting till my next go-round to write the review, but sometimes courses put words in my head, and I had to get these ones out. I returned to the course this morning and I still couldn't help but be amazed by how well-crafted the course is.