It wasn't meant to be so negative, just points of it ended up that way. As the OP, what I've taken away from this thread so far is that unless you play 5 PDGA events a year, you don't "make" your money back. However, there are other intrinsic reasons to join, such as contributing to an organization that helps support the sport, the sense of inclusion that comes with being part of an organization, the sense of pride in having your own PDGA number, and of course not paying the extra $10 non-member fee at tournaments.
On the other hand, you can still support and grow the sport though service (course cleanup and maintenance), teaching new players, and countless other ways. Many folks have their leagues that they belong to, so are already a part of a disc golf community.
Ultimately, the decision is a personal one and I just hope anyone really considering joining the PDGA can find what they need to make an informed decision
Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk