Pros:
+ This place is dedicated to disc golfing only. There is virtually zero chance of dog walkers, joggers, bicyclists and birdwatchers getting in the way... probably. I've only been here once.
+ A nice welcome area with decent parking, shaded practice basket, picnic benches, trash cans, plastic outhouse and a lost disc box. (Was there a lost disc box? I can't remember now.)
+ A "current basket" system is in use. Colored clamps cover the corresponding pin position as indicated on the sign post.
+ Tee pads are well-upkept rubber anchored into wood frames, but....
Cons:
- ...Some of those tees are slanted. Hole14's springs to mind.
- Some baskets are visibly damaged like hole8's. Also, most are dull and hard to see for being in a mostly wooded environment.
- There are no navigation signs after each hole. Yes, the course is largely straightforward, but for the parts that aren't, a player can get turned around and lost. Between 7&8 and 14&15 are the biggest culprits of this.
Other Thoughts:
This review is based on my experience with the short layout.
I liked the visual appeal of hole17 because of how twisty, wooded and shadowy it is. I enjoyed playing hole14 the most because of its crazy downhill tunnel. Hole10 felt the most boring to my mind because of how flat and wide open it is.
But boring holes at Scarboro could easily be the most exciting at many other courses. There is a dedicated following behind Scarboro Hills, and it is not at all hard to see why. This course has expansive grassland, a quiet forest, trickling waterways and impressive hills. This place feels hand-selected and tailor made for disc golf.
That is seen in many of the holes all around the course. An easy example is hole3 with its lovely downhill slope and narrow tunnel at the same time. Also, hole7 is a nice upslope that starts sunny and open before just entering into the forest edge. Because there are no playgrounds or walking paths to worry about, the course can sprawl wherever and however it likes. And the player can throw with reckless abandon with no fear of hitting anyone or anything. In brief, it feels freeing to play here because there are all kinds of fairways on offer.
I should point out that it can be a bit confusing to find your way, though. Instinct and common sense prevail most times, but there are certain points where you have three paths in front of you and no indication of which is the right way. For example, after hole7 I accidentally wound up at hole16 because that route felt more natural to me. So, some nav signs would be nice to see. Also, the baskets are tough to spot. Much of the course plays in a forest with overlapping shadows, which subdues the metallic grey targets. Adding flags or swapping them out with brighter colored ones would help this.
But the disc golfing itself is a joy. It's a rare treat to encounter a course that accommodates players of all styles. Open and wooded fairways are on equal display here. They aren't terribly long, either. Even from the longest layout, distances rarely exceed 350 feet. So new players can have a fun time here, too, as long as they don't mind hitting trees along the way.
Bottom line: Scarboro Hills is a shotgun blast of fairways that deserve your attention. It is a secluded piece of property that is well taken care of. Some infrastructure and navigation issues subtract from the rating that could have been, but I think it's every disc golfer's desire to play at a grab bag of a course like this. Strongly recommended.