Possibly hot take. Super thin and breathable shoes (I currently wear Xero shoes on the course) with a waterproofing spray and extra socks for worst case scenario is way better than a waterproof shoe. It's not a matter of if your feet get wet but when, even with gortex, and waterproof shoes take ages to dry out.
I played a tournament last month, first hole of round two threw into some foot deep casual water and my casual relief would have taken me OB so my options were walk in a play my shot or go 400ft back to the tee and throw 3. Rolled my pants up and played it from the water. 2 hole later I finally had a minute to change my socks and the shoes were already completely dry. I've had waterproof shoes in the past that have taken over an entire day siting outside before they dried out.