Pros:
Agape Farm is the latest top-notch Championship Course in this part of the state, and boy is it something! Immense elevation, creatively challenging par 5s, and gorgeous views across many acres of a Christian camp.
Three layouts plus a fourth championship layout (whose baskets were not in for the tournament I played in). The Reds (8,252') play quite comfortably to par while the Blues (11,098') are a nice challenge. Goldilocks Whites come in at 9,733'.
Not as many of those patented John Houck double fairways as some of his other courses, but there are plenty of decisions to make on all of the par 4's and 5's, as there are not many flat landing zones to choose from.
Large pristine tee-pads, great signage, and perhaps the most efficient design from hole to hole that I've experienced on a Championship-level course like this, hardly any time spent walking from one basket to the next tee.
On the longer holes, the greens themselves are numbered with clear signage so new players don't have to squint and wonder if they're throwing to the right basket.
The back 9 in particular is quite picturesque as you move further away from the rest of the course and the camp infrastructure.
The par 5s are really worth singing about. One or two (depending on the layout) on the front nine and three on the back nine. The first one, hole 5 (1095'), asks you to throw straight across from one hill to another, hopefully progressing far enough that on your second shot you can punch through a gap in the trees to get into the open. Your final approach is across an open field downhill into a tiny green cut out into the edge of the woods.
Hole 13, coming in at over 1300'(!) asks you to beat a few trees off the tee, throwing slightly downhill and hopefully avoiding getting caught up by branches too high. If you fade too far left along the slope of the hill than the best you can hope for your second shot is to make it just through the gap, setting you up to throw up over an open rise, which should get you close enough for an easy though somewhat blind approach to a basket nestled in a depression with several guardian trees and a slope that loves rollaways drifting away past the basket.
I love hole 9, which I have yet to figure out after three rounds. Par 4, 651' from the blues, it forces you to throw a very straight shot through several gaps that lands in a very specific landing zone which will allow you to throw a delicate BH turnover or maybe a flippy FH down a gradual slope to the green that skips quite quickly into the pond beyond.
Cons:
It's a great course and an absolutely blast to play, the designers and the whole Agape Farm team have really gone above and beyond to put a beautiful course in the ground. But there are just a few things holding it back from being 5 stars:
There are three holes that feel a bit like filler in my opinion, hole 6, hole 12 (which feel like a real missed opportunity to push a little further into the woods to make a par 4), and hole 16.
Similar to Muddy Run, holes 17 and 18 are just wide-open bomber holes. I think these holes would be totally fine within the context of the whole round, but not the most magical way to end a round and they feel like they stick out from the rest of the course in an underwhelming way.
The course had been whipped into great shape by the grounds crew for the Grand Opening tournament but the rough still feels raw in some places and the fairways are not quite beaten in yet. I suspect it'll take plenty of maintenance to keep Nature at bay and I wonder if a course this far out will ever get enough traffic to feel comfortable softened up into that perfect space.
Other Thoughts:
$12 to play, there's a drop box at the first tee.
Plenty of bathrooms throughout.
There's a pitch and putt micro-course on-site as well.
RV parking and amenities.
I think a brief comparison to the other big boy course in the area, Faylor Lake, would be helpful to draw out some of the virtues of both courses:
Agape Farm is absolutely challenging on every shot. There is aggressive utilization of elevation throughout, greens are sloped, second shots on fairways are almost always forcing you to deal with unbalanced footing and throwing up hill or downhill.
Agape is, I feel, also more mentally demanding. Hole to hole, Faylor mostly asks you land your tee shots in a few particular places, and challenges you to figure out what type of throw to get there, while Agape allows you to play your game off the tee to land in a variety of spots, but you may not know clearly what spot is best.
I do find Agape plays easier to par than Faylor but the physical and mental experience of a round at Agape is more taxing. Which isn't necessarily a bad thing!
Agape is a little less picturesque and lacks some of the water danger of Faylor, but Agape's big bomber holes feel a little more natural (though perhaps also a little less memorable).
Definitely play them both and decide for yourself!