• Discover new ways to elevate your game with the updated DGCourseReview app!
    It's entirely free and enhanced with features shaped by user feedback to ensure your best experience on the course. (App Store or Google Play)

Sauk Rapids, MN

Mayhew Creek Park

3.895(based on 9 reviews)
Filter course reviews

Filter reviews

Filter reviews

Mayhew Creek Park reviews

Filter
0 1
Spike Hyzer 23
Experience: 30.8 years 92 played 88 reviews
3.50 star(s)

Long, open and very challenging 2+ years drive by

Reviewed: Played on:Feb 10, 2017 Played the course:once

Pros:

It's a spectacular piece of land, is well designed and easy to follow, has great baskets, and the tees are paving blocks which were remarkably even and not problematic.

The elevation on the first two holes open holes made for a nice warm up.

The next four holes were really nice technical holes that favored a lefty for getting a deuce (and you'd better get your deuces on the shorter holes).

The 7th is a huge bomber that puzzled me (see cons).
The 8th is a nice short technical birdie hole.
The 9th is a challenge to get 3 (I can see why it's par 4).
The 10th is long with a nice protected green.

The 13th is a beautiful open shot that must go into a tunnel that is over 240' away and runs along the creek. A lefty would be tempted to hang a hyzer out over the creek. Don't.
The 14th is a very challenging technical hole.


Cons:

It's astonishingly long and deserving of the par 71 rating (though I might put that a little bit lower, perhaps around 62).

Some of the distances seem wildly inaccurate, while most are spot on.

The 5th is listed at 695 from the Pro and it goes about 140 to the Am and then turns left and is straight. The problem is that the Am is listed at 349 and it is easly 449. I hit a tree at about 200 and still had 250 and couldn't reach with a driver.

The 7th is listed at 588, and I went driver and midrange and was 22 feet past. There was a tail wind and my max driver distance is 330 and my max mid is 250, which is 580. I did drive about 300 and maxed my mid, so I would have to estimate that the hole is only 530 (because I went past).

The 9th is listed at 335. I drove 253' straight down the middle and had a perfect 120' second. The hole is surely closer to 375.

The 10th is listed at 360. I had a perfect drive of 256' straight down the middle and my second was 81' to the pin. This seems closer to 337.

15 may be the most difficult hole I've ever played. Not in a good way.

The 17th and 18th are unbelievably tough and very long and probably always into a brutal south/west wind. I walked away disappointed, believing I'd ruined a decent round by finishing bogie bogie. The hole info here tells me that I shot par, birdie to finish.

The course is deserving of a par rating of more than 54, but it is not a 71 as the course information declares.

Here are the holes that are rated one stroke too tough (shorts):
Hole 2 should be par 3.
Hole 5 should be par 4.
Hole 6 should be par 3.
Hole 7 should be par 4.
Hole 9 should be par 3.
Hole 10 should be par 3.
Hole 11 should be par 4.
Hole 16 should be par 3.
Hole 18 should be par 4.

This would bring the Am tee par down to 62.

The only other oddity is that the gold tees are the short.

Designers need to realize that the ball golf tradition is, in order of easiest to hardest:
Red
White
Blue
Gold/Black
(we don't typically see more than 4 sets of tees and gold or black is what follows blue)

Other Thoughts:

Hmmm...perhaps the person who entered the data reversed the pars.

The 8300 foot Pro Tees are listed as par 64, and the 6300 feet Am Tees are listed as par 71!!

This should clearly be reversed, though I'd still rate the Am Tees around a par 62. The Pros could be more than 71, but maybe only a couple of strokes.

I will add that I don't normally like open, long, boring courses, but this is not that open and not boring at all. It will wear a player out, but it's a great workout and will challenge all your skills.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
0 2
reichmusic
Experience: 10 years 13 played 10 reviews
3.50 star(s)

Grassy 2+ years drive by

Reviewed: Played on:Aug 3, 2015 Played the course:once

Pros:

Concrete pads
Good flow, signage
Multiple pads for pro/amateur
Mostly wide open for bombers
The couple of woods holes provided much needed variety

Cons:

Number 5 pro tee line didn't make sense, short 100 feet to get to the short tee then turn more then 90 degrees to the right

By hole 16 I was tired of the long field play.....

Thick high grasss in the rough, easy to lose a disc

The grass wasn't cut when I went from hole 15 on- it was unpleasant, glad the whole place wasn't like that.

Other Thoughts:

Really enjoyed my hour long speed round. Good for beginner and expert. Pars were manageable for a newer golfer, but the long tees provided a scoring challenge.

Nice place to start learning distance combined with accuracy.....you'll be able to be punished but still get to see your disc sore...(not hitting a tree)


Was this review helpful? Yes No
4 0
mndiscg
Diamond level trusted reviewer
Experience: 16 years 483 played 478 reviews
3.50 star(s)

Not my kind of course 2+ years

Reviewed: Played on:Aug 23, 2014 Played the course:once

Pros:

+Dual concrete pads at every hole.
+Quality baskets
+Easy navigation, just follow mowed paths for the most part. Very intuitive.
+Great signage at both tees. Short tees signs were larger with more information.
+Mostly open bomber type of course but there were a few wooded holes early on.
+Some decent elevation changes early and some minor rolling hills later on. Holes 1 and 2 were a great start to the course in this regard.
+Giant course map at start near high school's parking lot. Lots of parking when school is not in session. Not sure about when it is.
+Bathroom on site.
+Championship level distances on this course. If you like to throw far, you will like to play here.
+There was no garbage on the course and the fairways seem to be mowed often. It was in great shape.

Cons:

-Many holes were too open and there were few shot shaping requirements on these holes. If you went into the rough you had a great chance of losing your disc but that was the only penalty.
-It's way too easy to lose discs here in the long grass. On hole 5, I threw my Striker from the short pad and it went about 350', faded slightly right and bounced a short way into the rough. I couldn't find it.
-Hole 5 was also odd shaped from the long tee. There might be a local line but otherwise it seemed like you just had to toss a short one out there to the short tee and then shoot again.
-This is one of those courses that seemed to be long just for the sake of being long and using up more land. I don't have a huge arm and don't like to throw all out on most tees and even more than once on some holes. I much prefer the woods and risk/reward shots that reward control and accuracy.

Other Thoughts:

-This course had a pretty low fun factor for me. I respect the challenge of the course and could see how it might be fun to play a tournament here but it isn't a course that I would enjoy playing every day. This is why I couldn't give it the 4 that others before me had.
-This course is definitely worth a stop, especially if you like to throw long. You won't be disappointed unless you are looking for a tight woods course.
-There are a lot of good courses in the St Cloud area and this is one of them. Other good ones include Hidden Lake, Millstream, Cavalry Hill, and Riverside. This course probably rounds out that top 5.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
Top