Pros:
(4.187 Rating) (RE-EVALUATED) A huge hybrid parks style and woods course with a ton of variety and two distinguished sets of tees to test the game on.
- HOLE VARIETY - Excellent. The first seven holes at Tom Brown are all different. An openish shot on (1), then a moderately wooded play on (2), a wooded pocket to hit on (3), a heavily wooded dogleg par 4 on (4), a lightly wooded play on (5), a technical hook on (6) and an uphill wooded play on (7). What a nice mix to start off. However, once I hit hole (8) my jaw dropped as there is just an amazing run of awesome tee shots. Several holes on this course could be the signature hole on 80 percent of the courses out there. I keep a running list of my favorite 100 holes ever played (over 6500 unique holes played as of this revision), and I still have 2 holes at Tom Brown on the list. Hole (C) is my personal favorite, where it's a 150 foot long tunnel shot atop a ridge and over a creek and into a meadow. The next shot to the basket plays across a shallow creek and is well guarded by numerous pines. Another shallow creek lies beyond as well for those that are too aggressive. There are very few similar shots on this course and I can still visually remember them all 3 years later.
- HOLES A THRU F - The course is laid out in a way so that when one finishes hole (9) they can either play a loop of six bonus holes labeled (A, B, C, D, E, F) or move right onto (10). Do not skip these holes if you are here for the first time. IMO, 5 of the best 9 holes at Tom Brown are in this loop.
- ELEVATION FOR FLORIDA - Amongst the biggest elevation changes I've seen on a Florida course (114 Florida courses played as of this revision). There are several holes that change by over 30 feet and a couple are in the 40 foot range. Still not as much as the courses 4 hours to the north, but a welcome surprise to those expecting just another flat Florida course.
- TEES - Wow did this course drop some money on the tees. Long and wide for both pros and ams. In addition, several tees are on raised platforms boxed by heavy timbers. 446 courses in now, and Tom Brown is still in my top 10 for the tees.
- EQUIPMENT AND EXTRAS - In addition to the amazing tees, Tom Brown has a lot of the niceties that one would expect of an established course with a great club presence. Practice basket, community board, tables, benches, shelters, multiple pin placements, Veteran baskets and a disc return box.
- CHALLENGING - Not as challenging as nearby Jack McLean, but the challenge from the backs will still very much push your typical Advanced player to break par. At the 2017 Tally open, and with all placements in the far position, only 17 of the 39 open players broke par on their round (par 81). The round was officially rated at 984, ie shooting even par got you that rating. Even in a normal mix of placements, the back tees are going to test all the skills of veteran players. There's some short technical plays and some long bombs. Hole management even comes into play on a few of the par 4s where placement and execution are key.
- SKILL LEVEL FRIENDLY - Tom Brown is ideal for a wide swath of skill levels. The red tees are perfect for Recreational players. I could also see beginners enjoying it as well with a skip of the bonus holes. The back tees will appease most Advanced players and Intermediates.
- NATURAL BEAUTY - Some pretty amazing scenery on many of the holes. The best part is clearly the middle portion. I'd give the stretch of holes, 7 thru 11 (includes hole A thru F) a 4.25 out of 5. But the rest of the course does bring it back a little. The abandoned tee pads are a minor eyesore and there's some trash issues. Some may also consider the power lines running down holes (A and B) to be less than ideal, but IMO the power line path offered up its space for a wonderful wide dogleg right down shot.
- EVENTS - This course is known to hold major tournaments in the region and state. So if you're into tournaments you'll want to schedule a weekend here.
Cons:
An excellent course with only ticky tack issues.
- PAR - I don't understand the par switching on some holes. There are several holes where the par will switch from a par 3 to a par 4 for the pro tees (blue) depending on basket location. Yet the ams tees (red) will still stay a par 3. Hole (E) is a good example of this where the farther pin placement from the pro tee is a par 4 at 480 feet, yet from the ams its a par 3 at 415 feet.
- SPACING - Low use park roads and walking trails come into play on several holes. Over 3 rounds here, I waited only a couple times for a walker or car to pass. Overall a very minor issue. I could name more than 50 courses in Florida with worse spacing issues.
- PARKING - Despite all the money dropped to revise this course, the one thing that didn't change was the horrible parking area. Pitted, uneven and unpaved. Thankfully for the courses sake, it only affected my rating of the course by .03 points.
- TIME PLAY - This beast is going to take some time out of your day, which can play sometimes at over 10,000 feet from the back tees. I ran between some holes and it still took me nearly 90 minutes to complete this one. Figure your average group of 4 skilled players will play this in 3 to 3 1/2 hours.
Other Thoughts:
I've played 114 Florida courses, including all of top ten on DGCR, and this is without question one of the best in Florida. The only course I've personally enjoyed more in Florida, was New World, which has a bit more variety with its decadent water plays and it has golf carts you can zip around on. As for the Tallahassee course scene, This is the top dog without question. Maybe 1 in 8 random players will prefer Jack over Tom. Jack appeals to the small niche of woods players that are likely masochists. I do like Jack though, its beautiful and challenging, I just don't like having the same two plays, twelve times each. Anyways, back to Tom Brown, this is an Excellent course. I originally scored it at a 4.269, but I've now seen an additional 300 courses. I reran the numbers with my updated scoring method and I also used info from the last few reviews. With this, I got a revised score below the 4.25 threshold, hence this revision. Regardless of me dropping it a peg, this is a destination course for the panhandle. I've played just about every course within two hours of here and none of them come close. Actually, Jack would be second imo. If you find yourself traveling along I10 you need to check this monster course out.
- SIGNAGE AND NAVIGATION - I have heard that this has degraded quite a bit since I was last here. There has been some vandalism to the signs, and some have even disappeared. Be sure and download the DGCR map. If you do so, you should have no issues navigating this course first time solo. Next tee callouts are indicated on the hole signs that remain.