• Discover new ways to elevate your game with the updated DGCourseReview app!
    It's entirely free and enhanced with features shaped by user feedback to ensure your best experience on the course. (App Store or Google Play)

[Innova] champ sidewinder variations

Just went out to the field to confirm...
I was right the really old SW that is flat will turnover even when thrown on a spike hyzer line! It would make an awesome max D disc.
G star flips flat and turns over late.
Domey champ PFN Pre-www flips flat and goes straight, finishes straigt.

How would a Discmania C-TD compare?
 
C TD will be more overstable.
It can really ride a straight line, then fade, but you have to throw it harder.
 
I want to follow/add to this thread....

I've recently started throwing SWs and the 1st I bagged I fell in love with, and have been collecting up some, what I thought to be, backups.

I picked up the 1st one at PIAS. It was a 9/10 (w/ ink) PFN, Pre "www", Pearly, Champ @ 171g. It was a slight dome to it, and a concave (teebird-ish) wing. That thing is Stable, Completely Neutral! I can throw it full power with a slight hyzer release and it will simply flip flat and ride a lazer beam straight line for a looooong way! I love using it for long tunnel shots and placement shots. The wind only slightly effects it, and it really likes a tailwind. The only time I see any fade from it is when I get it up high or with a strong tailwind.

It quickly became a go-to/confidence control driver for me, so I instantly knew I needed backups.
I lucked into an X-out matching the same description at PIAS, that only has a touch more dome.

I also wanted a few more, so I picked up some off the forums that I believe to be older, bc the plastic feels more like early 11x type. I'm guessing these are from around 2004/2005. These are very flat, which I thought I would like, but they are max weight and flippy as crap! Both are brand new 10/10 (well I guess, 9/10 now that Ive tossed them in the field)

I thought maybe the GStar ones would be a good production replacment, so I picked up a 171g and 175g. Those are also super flippy. Now that being said, they will ride the longest HUGE turnover line I have ever thrown lol, but I dont really find myself needing big turnover shots often, certianly that my Leopard wont reach.

Now for the questions...

1) Which of my SWs are the way a SW "is supposed to fly" ??
2) I fondled a couple of the current production champ (JL?) and they do feel completely different, and I noticed the different wing. Being straighter/slanted more like a leopard or roadrunner, I assumed they would more US, so I left them on the shelf. Would they actually make a good replacment for the ones I like?

I just want that flip-to-flat and bomb out that I'm used to. A couple of my buddies I play with noticed me throwing a new mold and crushing some lasers with it, and asked "What is that??!". When I told them it was an old SW, they were like "NO WAY! Those are stupid flippy!". I said "this one's not!" and they told me, "just wait, once it beats in a little it will be". Well, since I use it a lot for wooded tight tunnels, it has taken some pretty strong hits, and its has yet to change its flight. It still maintains that great laser line.

I did throw a very light (158-162-ish) Hatchet that a buddy let me try. I only threw it w a decent tailwind, but it did seem to have a similar flight. Not sure it was as fast or covered as much distance as my SW though.

I need something in that control driver speed range, bc I dont want to overlap my FWs. Those molds are set.

3) Do I simply just need to look for PFN Champs that are Domey?

I do have a couple PFN stars in max weight that are new, but I havent tried them yet. They do have a slight dome, but not quite as much as my two favorite champs.

Sorry for the long post, but this exact topic has been on my mind recently.

Hopfully its not seen as a hy-jack.

from your other post as well. the td is dead straight and fades ok at the end. kind of like how a saint allegedly was supposed to be. funny though i bag saints and not tds (im too lazy to beat a td in, but if you have the patience it would make a fantastic turnover but out of the box it barely turns)

so your looking to find sidewinders that you can throw on a slight hyzer, will flip to flat and ride it out to end with no fade?

if so every preflight ive thrown does that. also the first run sidewinders fly just like the preflight ones. that, in my belief is how the sidewinders should fly. they had the more blunt nose compared to the newer runs that are out right now. the current runs are def more stable and i would say fly like close to how i described the td earlier. maybe a touch of more fade.

and dome doesnt really effect the flight as much as the PLH does.

did that answer your question well enough? if not keep going ill try to help haha
 
from your other post as well. the td is dead straight and fades ok at the end...

^^ I think I'll try one, hopefully I can find a C-line non-plus mold. I don't really want any fade at the end. Do these have a sweet spot, once seasoned, where there is little-to-no fade, but its not a turnover/flippy disc?

so your looking to find sidewinders that you can throw on a slight hyzer, will flip to flat and ride it out to end with no fade?...

^^ EXACTLY! :) I have two PFNs that do this perfectly (circa 2008 runs domey) , and two that flip like a Roadrunner/Fury from the 1st throw (circa 2004-05 flat)

...if so every preflight ive thrown does that. also the first run sidewinders fly just like the preflight ones....

Not sure why there is such a difference in the ones I have. All of them were new condition as of a couple months ago, other than one of the domey ones which I found at PIAS used. Its actually the most stable one lol.

...that, in my belief is how the sidewinders should fly... dome doesnt really effect the flight as much as the PLH does.

Glad to hear you say that! I totally agree! Thats exactly how I want them to fly.

Maybe it is the PLH making the difference and its just a coincidence about the domes, I'll check them this afternoon. The earlier flat ones are from a very tacky, gummy-ish, CE like run, and the later domey ones are from a standard Champion run (nice and grippy, feel similar to late 11x/early 12x champ plastic)

...did that answer your question well enough? if not keep going ill try to help haha

Yes, for the most part. Thank you!

Are the speeds and glides similar between the C-TD and the PFN SWs?

The biggest reason I'm focused on this stems from a tourney I played in this weekend.
I changed my bag up to orange discs for spring (from Dayglow) with "carbon copies" of the same molds I carry. I only had a few days to do field work with my new discs. Granted my Leopard was more stable b/c it was fresh, but I know how to compensate for that. Other than that, the rest of the replacments behaved very close to the discs they replaced.
Now to the Point...
I was on a hole that tees from the top of a large bank/hill ~25ft above the long straight FW below. The FW is gaurded by two mature long leaf pines growing from the bottom of the bank. It forces a low cieling drive and prevents a big hyzer release. The hole is a par 4 around 425-450. Once past the trees, the FW is straight and open. Normally this hole has a prevailing tailwind and b/c of that I would throw my SW inlieu of my Destroyer bc I can rip it on a low line that will split the gap, once the elevation drops out under it the SW's glide takes over and it bombs out and doesnt fade off the FW.

Well on this day, there was a strong headwind coming in, and I knew this new flat SW was more US than my previously bagged one. My judgment of the headwind lead me to pull out the G*D. Well, the headwind was stronger than I imagined, and the Destroyer flipped right out of my hand and clipped the overhanging limbs from the left tree sending my drive off to the right and landing right behind a pile of large fallen limbs at the bottom of the hill/bank. (I'm LHBH BTW)

From this lie, at least I was looking at a clear shot of the FW, but I had a long way to go and couldnt get a proper run up. I felt like I was under the strongest part of the headwind and knew I could get good power on my stand still throw. I figured I could rip my SW on a decent hyzer release from a static throw , and ride the wind up the FW.

Well it was a good plan, I got a strong rip on it and it was on line for about 50 ft then that bad boy turned over and flew way to the left over by the next hole's teepad. It covered the distance, but I was pin high 65 ft off to the left from my line. I was able to get a good approach and save par, but that stroke would have made a big difference in my finishing position.

I just know that my other SW would have held the line with the amount of hyzer release I put on it. I could have clubed down and used maybe my leopard or TB but I would have had no chance covering the distance I needed. As it turned out, I guess it wouldnt have made much difference, as I had a long approach anyway. I just felt really let down by my disc. I rarely blame the arrow, bc its usually the archer who made the mistake. I suppose my mistake was disc selection, maybe I should have chosen something slower.
I saw a tip from Feldberg recently where he said to try "flying" a slower mid-stable disc into a headwind as opposed to a faster more OS one. He said the faster disc didnt have time to react to the wind, and was trying too hard to fight against it, causing it to lose momentum and thus distance. Being a mechanical engineer, that got my wheels turning a bit. I'm going to try it in the field next time there is some good wind blowing.

Anyway...Sorry for the long post. I know this isnt a blog lol
 
^^ I think I'll try one, hopefully I can find a C-line non-plus mold. I don't really want any fade at the end. Do these have a sweet spot, once seasoned, where there is little-to-no fade, but its not a turnover/flippy disc?



^^ EXACTLY! :) I have two PFNs that do this perfectly (circa 2008 runs domey) , and two that flip like a Roadrunner/Fury from the 1st throw (circa 2004-05 flat)



Not sure why there is such a difference in the ones I have. All of them were new condition as of a couple months ago, other than one of the domey ones which I found at PIAS used. Its actually the most stable one lol.



Glad to hear you say that! I totally agree! Thats exactly how I want them to fly.

Maybe it is the PLH making the difference and its just a coincidence about the domes, I'll check them this afternoon. The earlier flat ones are from a very tacky, gummy-ish, CE like run, and the later domey ones are from a standard Champion run (nice and grippy, feel similar to late 11x/early 12x champ plastic)



Yes, for the most part. Thank you!

Are the speeds and glides similar between the C-TD and the PFN SWs?

The biggest reason I'm focused on this stems from a tourney I played in this weekend.
I changed my bag up to orange discs for spring (from Dayglow) with "carbon copies" of the same molds I carry. I only had a few days to do field work with my new discs. Granted my Leopard was more stable b/c it was fresh, but I know how to compensate for that. Other than that, the rest of the replacments behaved very close to the discs they replaced.
Now to the Point...
I was on a hole that tees from the top of a large bank/hill ~25ft above the long straight FW below. The FW is gaurded by two mature long leaf pines growing from the bottom of the bank. It forces a low cieling drive and prevents a big hyzer release. The hole is a par 4 around 425-450. Once past the trees, the FW is straight and open. Normally this hole has a prevailing tailwind and b/c of that I would throw my SW inlieu of my Destroyer bc I can rip it on a low line that will split the gap, once the elevation drops out under it the SW's glide takes over and it bombs out and doesnt fade off the FW.

Well on this day, there was a strong headwind coming in, and I knew this new flat SW was more US than my previously bagged one. My judgment of the headwind lead me to pull out the G*D. Well, the headwind was stronger than I imagined, and the Destroyer flipped right out of my hand and clipped the overhanging limbs from the left tree sending my drive off to the right and landing right behind a pile of large fallen limbs at the bottom of the hill/bank. (I'm LHBH BTW)

From this lie, at least I was looking at a clear shot of the FW, but I had a long way to go and couldnt get a proper run up. I felt like I was under the strongest part of the headwind and knew I could get good power on my stand still throw. I figured I could rip my SW on a decent hyzer release from a static throw , and ride the wind up the FW.

Well it was a good plan, I got a strong rip on it and it was on line for about 50 ft then that bad boy turned over and flew way to the left over by the next hole's teepad. It covered the distance, but I was pin high 65 ft off to the left from my line. I was able to get a good approach and save par, but that stroke would have made a big difference in my finishing position.

I just know that my other SW would have held the line with the amount of hyzer release I put on it. I could have clubed down and used maybe my leopard or TB but I would have had no chance covering the distance I needed. As it turned out, I guess it wouldnt have made much difference, as I had a long approach anyway. I just felt really let down by my disc. I rarely blame the arrow, bc its usually the archer who made the mistake. I suppose my mistake was disc selection, maybe I should have chosen something slower.
I saw a tip from Feldberg recently where he said to try "flying" a slower mid-stable disc into a headwind as opposed to a faster more OS one. He said the faster disc didnt have time to react to the wind, and was trying too hard to fight against it, causing it to lose momentum and thus distance. Being a mechanical engineer, that got my wheels turning a bit. I'm going to try it in the field next time there is some good wind blowing.

Anyway...Sorry for the long post. I know this isnt a blog lol

i am not sure about the sweet spot on the tds. i didnt use mine long enough to see its wear.

the flippy sidewinders...are they the opaque super grippy runs?

i would say the td has less glide than a sidewinder but you can still get great distance out of it. release it almost flat and it just stays flat its hole flight and casually fades out at the end. no turn really. its a crazy straight disc with a little fade.

its hard to say cuz i wasnt there, and there are so many variables with the wind and everything. maybe it was bad disc selection, maybe there was a nasty pocket of air that got under the disc. the more i think about it, if your gstarrr d flipped a sidewinder is more likely than not to flip

the newest runs i found to fight the wind better but thats only cuz there more OS compared to other runs. but opinion on that may vary
 
MVP Inertia. I have about 7 PFN champ SW's but was wanting something a little different. I really really dig the Inertia. It may be tad bit faster and a little more glidey but it is the closest thing that I have thrown that compares to a SW to me.

Cow
 
PLH domey left, flat right.
The flat one actually has a higher PLH, but like I said before, I threw them side by side yesterday in the field w no wind and the flat one turns over big time.
I even threw them both on a spike hyzer line, domey rode the line and the flat still flipped.
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    69.3 KB · Views: 63
weird your flippy ones look just like the nice neutral ones im used to. they have turn but nothing too bad. they fight the wind alright too for an understable disc. i thought you had the champystar ish blend
 
Top