Pros:
Location. It's private, isolated, beautiful, set in the rolling hills on a great piece of wooded property around the Menomonie area. Many holes offer sweeping vistas of the surrounding properties and terrain. It's extremely beautiful here. Being a private course, you can really lose yourself and enjoy a nice quiet round.
Balance and variety. As the pictures and E-Rock's review will show you, you get a very mix of long/short, open/wooded, uphill/downhill/crosshill, right/left/straight, water/OB/mandos/punishing rough, etc. You will find yourself using a wide range of discs on this course, except when it's windy, then maybe 5.
No garbage cans. You heard me correctly, this is a private course, and if you packed in your beer bottles, you can pack them out, why make Steve work any harder and also risk litter scattered all over his land.
Decent benches all around the property, and a firepit area at a 'crossroads' on the property with holes 5, 6, 7.
Cons:
I was extremely let down by the tees here. Not the fact that they are natural, but that many have had no attempt to level them out whatsoever. I'm talking, lumpy, rocky, root riddled uphill sloping tees on various holes. Hole 12 did a decent job of trying to level out the tees, but the effort still falls a bit short with lumps and rocks left on the tee. It was also very disappointing to play a PDGA A-Tier on these types of pads. Quite a few could be easily leveled out, even if they stayed natural/dirt. A few loads of crushed stone would do wonders for the tee surfaces. I'd have no expectations for concrete or rubber mats on a private course - way too much cost.
Complete balance and variety within the course could be so much better with multiple tees and multiple pin locations. Only a few of the open hilly holes had multiple tees. I believe these two aspects are absolutely required for any course to receive high ratings. It's nice to play a single 18 hole course in various ways by utilizing shorter red level tees for beginners or ace runs for experienced players, and also add longer alternate pin placements which turn the short tees into white level tees, or long tees into gold level tees.
Personally I would have cut more holes into the really tight wooded sections of the property. Only 4, 9, and 10 I would considerd fully wooded. The love of wooded holes is a preference, but the property seems to be able to support a bit more of that very tightly wooded mix.
No tee signs whatsoever. Personally I like signs, even simple handmade ones. I like a generic depiction of the hole and prominent features and I like to see the distance. If more pins and tees were added, tee signs would be a must.
Playing in the summer is probably a chore with all the long grass and many many closed up lines through the woodsonce leaves sprout.
It's $5, and with natural pads and a collection of baskets from around the state, that must all go toward gas to mow all the open holes.
It's just the weather, nothing about the course, but 3 rounds (two slow/boring pace of play tournament rounds) in 40+mph winds and 35-45 degree temps can really take their toll. My face actually peeled from all the windburn.
Other Thoughts:
I really think this course only falls in as a 3.0 because of the lack of better tees, just single tees, and just single pin locations. I'm torn because the seclusion and beauty of the area is really nice and makes me want to rate it higher. But then I think about how boring the last 5 holes are. I think they would have been more fun though if any of the 3 rounds I played here had less than 30-40mph winds.
While I was initially disappointed after my first round at the hyped axledog, I also continued to be disappointed. I don't know if I was in a bad mood from all the poor weather, but I never really got into the course. I've often stated how I walk around looking at courses and how I would design a hole differently - I did that a lot here. To each his own, and my preference dictates the review and rating I've given. I am taking NOTHING away from the hard work and dedication that Steve puts into the course, but I am also not giving credit for it, just reviewing the course as a course, nothing more.
I'd come back to play here again, no doubt, especially after getting in a few more rounds on all the layouts at Brickyard. If there were two tees on every hole, and alternate pin placements (easily done - many baskets are portables!) I could easily bump my rating to a 4.0 and possibly a 4.5 if even more risk and variety and unique terrain were brought into that mix.
I feel I may still be overinflating the rating with a 3.5 though.