Pros:
-Course was redisgned this year, and the new layout is much improved. Flows much more naturally as a disc golf course.
-Varied hole lengths, with some short holes, medium length holes, and holes your can crush on and still not get there
-Varying course conditions demand you account for them and adjust your shots accordingly. A shot that is parked one day might skip 70 feet past the basket another day. Some may think this is not a "pro", but I like that you might have to play completely different round to round, keeps things fresh.
-Good variety of right turning, left turning, and straight shots
-No losing your discs in the ponds! They are frozen. This is minnesota
-The teepads are (mostly) great when they are cleared off, the rubber provides a lot of grip.
-Navigation was easy, as you can see all the trampled snow from everyone walking to the next hole.
-Lots of birdie ops IF YOU EXECUTE, but generally not overly punishing if you don't
-Location is great. There is a shortage of convenient 18 hole courses on this side of town, especially in winter since Bryant Lake closes for the season. Very easy to get to if you want to play a full 18 hole course.
-Assuming it hasn't snowed within about a week, enough people play it that if you stay on the fairway, your disc usually wont go missing, as much of the snow gets trampled down
-The people that play in winter are not usually casual players. You generally don't get stuck behind chuckers that don't know to let faster players play through.
-Although there are no trash cans (see cons), course has generally been very clean, haven't seen much trash on the course at all
-Great use of the natural features of the par 3 golf course, including pin location, avoiding having too many point and shoot wide open holes with nothing in the way.
-Sometimes the course plays easy, sometimes good scores are HARD, due to any missed putts sliding 50 feet on ice. I like that.
Cons:
-Biggest issue with this course is DRAINAGE. There are a LOT of places on this course where water settles, then freezes into a giant sheet of ice that will never give you good footing.
-When the course was redesigned, these drainage issues were not fully taken into account. Some teepads are literally under inches of ice, totally unusable. As such, sometimes I have had to either throw off to the side on something vaguely grippy, or change the "teebox" to a completely different area that is not the official start of the hole. On one hole, players have stoped out an area in the cattails of a pond as the teebox will not be usable at all this season.
-Many of the ponds were originally surrounded with very thick trees and brush. This year, all of that was cleared out, turning some technical shots and interesting greens into wide open holes that IMO are much less fun. I liked having to take a technical downhill anny shot instead of a pretty standard hyzer shot sometimes. After talking to some of the people involved in designing the course, this was done by the golf course without telling or consulting the disc golf course designers, can't fault them for that really.
-Not all teepads are flat. Especially on one hole that comes to mind, that is at the top of a hill. No part of this teepad is flat, both the front and back of this teepad are sloped in opposite directions.
-No trash cans anywhere on the course, so you need to pack out everything you bring. I generally have not found this to be THAT much of an issue, players have done a good job of keeping the course clean.
-Sometimes things can get out of hand due to icy greens, big numbers can happen FAST. Don't know if I really consider this a con though. Make your putts.
Other Thoughts:
All in all, I like Brookview, it is my go to winter course, as BRP is kinda far and Bryant is closed all winter. It feels like the course was specifically designed for playing in winter, which, i suppose, it was! You really do have to be careful due to near constant icy conditions, it is very easy to slip and fall. There are issues, some of which can be resolved. You can't really fix the drainage, its just the way the land is. You CAN, however, put the teepads in a place where they won't be covered with a couple inches of ice for the whole winter. This is the first year of the redisign, so I expect a few teething issues until they figure everything out. Worth your time to check it out and play some winter disc golf!