Pros:
Hobbs Farm is a destination course. When you're rushing through Atlanta to get to a park in the middle of nowhere, it shows your appeal and quality.
- You want to see the makings of an absolute bemouth of a course? Just try to survive the first four holes with reasonable scores. Holes #2 & 4 are absolute beasts at 994 and 826 feet, respectively. This after getting to warm up on the 660-foot first hole, then catching your breath on the uphill, 270-foot third.
- #2 is the type of hole legends are made of. Idlewild has a hole of this quality; WR Jackson has a killer hole; and perhaps most comparable is Charlotte's Nevin #12. You start in an open field, throwing downhill. From there, you still have multiple shots into the woods and to the basket. I was content with my bogey 6. I guarantee I will never birdie this hole save for a hole-out from the fairway.
- #4 features the best aspects of the entire course into one hole. Long, dogleg right that starts uphill with the tee shot, plays downhill once you make the bend, then plays to a basket across a creek. The fairways are plenty wide with enough room to play around the trees that players can be aggressive with shots. Just don't go left into the rough as you approach the basket.
- Everything is relative, right? After the tough stretch to start the round, you get to #6, a 324-foot slight downhill hole. I normally approach holes like this thinking I've got an excellent chance to birdie this hole with a solid tee shot. Here, this hole seems like a pitch-and-putt shot, with me feeling I'm going to park this shot. A 10 to 15-foot birdie putt later, I was able to make up a stroke.
- #7 very well may be the second most daunting tee shot (after #17). There's tall, thick, lost-disc level of rough the entire right side of the fairway; however, you don't want to go too far left as that makes the approach shot up the hill more difficult. An excellent, station-to-station layout.
- #8 is an excellent risk/reward layout. A quick downhill, 291-foot par 3, with water coming into play for discs that sail long. A conservative tee shot should yield an easy par 3. An aggressive tee shot brings either birdie or bogey (or worse) into play. For someone like me, you're happy with the easy par 3 and will save the aggressiveness for later in the round.
- #17's tee shot is the lasting image for players. After #8, there's a long boardwalk over the water to the back portion of the course. Off that boardwalk are the tees (long & short) for #7. There's more than enough room for a full run-up. If you can throw straight, it's a rather simple par 3. Still, this goes down as one of the most scenic tee shots I've experienced, right up there with some of the top of the world shots at NC mountain courses.
- The final hole to point out is the peninsula water hole - #13. You're protected from the wind as you tee off in the woods. As soon as the disc gets over the water, (at least the day I played) you're at the mercy of winds whipping off the water. I watched my disc get caught up and sail off-line and splash down. The added challenge is that the peninsula doesn't have much depth to it. A shot sailing 25 feet longer than you intend, or one coming in heavy & taking a big skip, may end up in the water. I suspect there's some plastic in those waters.
- Tee signs are top of the line. Playing the course blind, I was able to rely on the tee signs for their accuracy versus having to take long walks down fairways to spot baskets, angles of doglegs, etc. Add to that the tee pads are excellent too.
- Course is surprisingly isolated from the rest of the park activities. The closest the course comes to interfering with other park activities is the path running along the right side of #9's fairway. I had to stop for a grand total of 30 seconds the entire round waiting for walkers.
Cons:
Crossing the boardwalk after #8, I was buying this course's hype. An elite level of holes had been played. Then, the course hits a stretch of open/field holes and take a dramatic step down.
- #10, 11, 15 & 18 are field holes. #10 offers a birdie chance as it's only 333 feet. The others are 500 feet plus, with only the uphill tee shot on #18 offering variety. From this stretch of holes, the most memorable part is the large tree by #11's tee and the partial ladder leading up it.
- #12 & 16 are wooded, but they're straight ahead, not-difficult layouts. I've already mentioned the ease of #17 as well.
- #13 is easily the best hole on the back nine, but that's a far cry from the level of holes #2, 4 & 7 on the front 9. Don't get me wrong. You've got to be a far better player than me to be getting birdie chances on these holes. I was getting one easy par after another without facing the risk of a bad score.
- Prepare for a lot of walking and some long transitions. The short tees are 3400 feet shorter than the longs. I can't imagine walking an extra 2/3 of a mile and not throwing. If you're here and you're going to be doing lots of walking, you might as well throw discs during that walk.
- Not a con, but an observation. This course is not beginner friendly. Bad rounds and bad experiences are the faults of underqualified players, not from the course's quality. Don't make the long drive (I'm assuming most readers of this aren't from Carrollton proper) and not be prepared for a tough course.
- A second observation. My first impression of the course was that of a letdown. Pulling into the compound and I notice the parking lot is on the backside of a church. My first thought, 'wait, don't tell me this is a church course and/or it's a shared space.' I don't know how the church services impact the course on Sunday mornings or during other service times.
Other Thoughts:
Hobbs Farm is an excellent course, no doubt about it. It's easily in the top 5 - 10% of the 300+ courses I've played. In terms of challenge, it's probably higher than that.
- That said, at its lofty 4.6something rating, it is overrated. Just in Georgia, WR Jackson and Steady Ed at the IDGC are both better quality courses. That said, if you are in the same conversation as those courses, you have a fantastic course.
- Bring your patience and lots to drink. This course is a grind. As fast as I play, it still took me nearly 90 minutes. Groups are going to be looking at 3 to 4 hour rounds so sit back and enjoy yourself.
- I hate how the finishing holes of some courses basically seem like they're built simply to get you back to the parking lot. It's as if course designers are backed into a corner and must design a layout with what's left of the land. That's what I felt was the situation with #18. There's plenty of room to be creative with the space for holes #1 through 17, and then suddenly, it's time to be straightforward and create something that leads players back to the beginning.
- I made this a destination course as a part of 37-hour, four state, 10-course trip. I left Charlotte at 3:45 on a Saturday morning and teed off at Hobbs by 8:15 on a crisp March morning. I'd gladly do the trip again just to play here again.
- The course's best holes compare with any course's best holes I've played. If you matched the top handful of holes here to other elite courses I've played (Idlewild, Harmon, WR Jackson, Panther Creek State Park), Hobbs Farm is right there with them. Once you get past that initial 6 - 8 holes, there's a separation from the quality of those courses to what's here. And that's why I'll rank this course a tad lower than those.
- All that said, this is a no-doubt must play. During the Covid-19 (I'm dating my review right here), I've seen on local club FB pages how many people don't even travel out of their own city to play courses. What a shame. If you're within several hours of this course, it's worth the drive.
- There are a few too many bland holes for this to be consider one of the elite. You'll notice a pattern that everyone talks about 2-7, 13, and 17....BUT, there isn't much love given to the other 10 holes. That's a glaring weakness.
- Whether you like my review or not, just remember that words are the money of fools (Hobbes).