SlothsLair
Newbie
Does this count as in? Thrown from 15' for par.
-
Discover new ways to elevate your game with the updated DGCourseReview app!
It's entirely free and enhanced with features shaped by user feedback to ensure your best experience on the course. (App Store or Google Play)
Does this count?
- Thread starter SlothsLair
- Start date
DROT (disc resting on basket). no it does not count / end thread.
Vondrehl has a diagram of nearly every possible situation that counts and does not count.
Vondrehl has a diagram of nearly every possible situation that counts and does not count.
Last edited:
SlothsLair
Newbie
Guess I'll add one to my last round then, dernit.
What Prerube said... except the "T" stand for "Top"
DSCJNKY
DSCJNKY
you mean Basket does not start with T? :doh: 
Skunk
Eagle Member
PhillyMatt
Broad Street Bully
Don't worry about it, we've all throw one of these before we knew the rule and were like "wtffffffff".
EDIT: yeah if i threw the yellow one, id would be in. Screw that ****.
Thank you for the Disc Tree. This was exactly what I was looking for! :clap:
PhillyMatt
Broad Street Bully
or one in the basket, but i guess that is self explanatory lol
Skunk
Eagle Member
The bottom right disc in that picture (the one wedged in the side of the basket) can be in or out depending on whether it entered from the inside or outside and whether it was witnessed. The others are all straightforward.
Skunk
Eagle Member
I would still count that on certain days as long as the thrower was able to get it before it hit the ground. FYI :thmbup:
What I don't understand is how the White disc is "in". The White disc isn't being supported by the chains... as it is wedged on the chain-holding-device in much the same way as the Yellow disc that is considered "out".
DSCJNKY
I think it is touching the basket, but being supported soley by chain.
^I thought he had it wedged on one of those inner chain hooks.
DSCJNKY
DSCJNKY
It looks too far inside to be touching one of those. If it were you would be correct that it should not count. It would have to be flipped around so the rim can get hooked.
Johnny Conservative
Banned
No it does not count. Seems like it would though because I think it is harder to get the disc to stick on top than put it in.
foo_g
Birdie Member
I don't have any statistical evidence, but I'd say that at least 95% of the answers to the "Does this count?" threads are "NO!". It's almost to the point that if you have to ask, it's not in. Throw again.
We just ran into a situation like the wedged disc. This was a possible ace, but the call was made that it was not. The disc was not visually witnessed, but no chain were heard to indicate it went through the basket somehow.
When reading the rules, 803.13B, it sounds like it should not count since it's not supported by the "inner cylinder" of the tray. If you read "Rules Changes 2011" it sounds like the wedgie would count if not witnessed. My question is, how is the wedgie considered supported by the "inner cylinder" of the tray?
Similar threads
