[Question] The DGCR Mold: Voting 1- disc type

[chevis]

lets's get this disc into reality. step one decide on type of disc. vote above.
reference: http://www.dgcoursereview.com/forums/showthread.php?t=126657

 

[Marmoset]

was there supposed to be a poll attached, vote in the thread you linked, or are we supposed to write our votes in this thread?
I'm confused...

 

[chevis]

should be there now?

 

[Marmoset]

Edit: I guess I missed the poll somehow, sorry about that.
Voted.

Thanks for making the poll!

 

[Reniger]

:thmbup: :thmbup: LID LOVERS UNITE!!!

 

[Marmoset]

I voted lid. If I had a second vote I would have gone for putter.

TurnBurn suggested this in the original thread and the idea is my #2 choice for this disc:

I'd like to see a decent driving putter mold (take you pick) with a "MAXIMUM DISTANCE PUTTER*" stamp on it, just to show and legitimize to people that they don't need a Boss on a 220' hole...

I really got into the Innova Stud because it was advertised as a shorter, slower Roc. This sounds fabulous on paper. In practice it doesn't quite hold up. There is not enough HSS for the Stud to carry the Roc comparison. The Stud is *okay* but I still want to find a shorter, slower, small diameter Roc-putter for cycling.

If we get a second vote then this is what I vote: keep everything about the Stud... low profile and all... but make it more HSS.

 

[jcassidy1990]

I voted lid. If I had a second vote I would have gone for putter.

TurnBurn suggested this in the original thread and the idea is my #2 choice for this disc:


I really got into the Innova Stud because it was advertised as a shorter, slower Roc. This sounds fabulous on paper. In practice it doesn't quite hold up. There is not enough HSS for the Stud to carry the Roc comparison. The Stud is *okay* but I still want to find a shorter, slower, small diameter Roc-putter for cycling.

If we get a second vote then this is what I vote: keep everything about the Stud... low profile and all... but make it more HSS.

Chief OS is very slow Roc like.
Check them out!

I vote lid.

 

[JamesXC]

If you make me a premium plastic Classic Roc or even just something that flies like it, I will buy 20.

 

[jskew113]

Lid.

 

[Keller]

There's enough of every thing else already out there, be different, not another "same as" lost in the shuffle!

Vote lid!

 

[mgamache8]

I'd live to be proven wrong, but I think if we go lid, then people will buy one the first year and then never buy one again. It will be a novelty disc, not something that people actually bag. But that's just my 2 cents

I voted fairway and I'd prefer a slower firebird like disc. A cross between the eagle-x and the whippet

 

[mgamache8]

And it should have been jcassidys decision to make this poll. Not anyone else's

 

[Mulligan]

TrollCat 1000%

 

[tylerc]

Chief OS is very slow Roc like.
Check them out!

I vote lid.

Chief os is a sweet flick upshot disc, been throwing it for a few weeks and really liking it.

 

[DanJon]

Low profile, smaller diameter lid.

Like a bigger Lil' Wiz.

 

[dwindacatcher]

That is called a resistor.

While a lid might not have the largest chance to be mass produced, it has the biggest chance to stay in peoples bags.

 

[@iDiscGolf]

If you make me a premium plastic Classic Roc or even just something that flies like it, I will buy 20.

They've made those. They didn't sell. Hence the, they don't make those anymore.

They had a very strange bubble too too...

 

[@iDiscGolf]

I'd live to be proven wrong, but I think if we go lid, then people will buy one the first year and then never buy one again. It will be a novelty disc, not something that people actually bag. But that's just my 2 cents

I voted fairway and I'd prefer a slower firebird like disc. A cross between the eagle-x and the whippet

Are you aware of how many company's are making a great Putter? A great midrange? A great fairway and distance driver? The market is doing just fine there...

How many good polecats are out there?

 

[mgamache8]

Are you aware of how many company's are making a great Putter? A great midrange? A great fairway and distance driver? The market is doing just fine there...

How many good polecats are out there?

I'm saying that there's a reason nobody makes a good polecat.......people don't buy them

 

[AndyJB]

Lid is smashing the competition...just what I wanted to see!