Pros:
- good variety of hole lengths and shot types
- practice basket
- large concrete tees
- bathrooms by parking lot (though locked in winter months)
- reflector strips on baskets help with visibility
- basic but serviceable baskets
- respectable elevation change due to numerous hills
- good number of mature tree obstacles require some shot shaping
- ample parking
- picturesque park with cool river views
- some cool throws from high elevation
- very clean and well maintained park
- no major safety hazards
- navigation is generally clear, though a few next tee signs could help
- park benches at some holes
Cons:
- no garbage cans (pack it out course, not necessarily a con if respected)
- tee signs are pretty basic and have no maps
- decent layer of leaf debris during winter months can swallow discs
- water hazards don't factor in much despite proximity to river
- can be a bit busy
Other Thoughts:
Lustig Park is a very respectable course in a strong disc golf state. I struggled to find many real cons for this course. While it may be about a 3.25 for me, I decided to give it the benefit of the doubt. A bit more technical wooded lines would make it better for me, but this is somewhat subjective.
It's hard to fault the design and layout of this course. While not championship caliber, it is well maintained and clean, navigation is clear, holes are challenging and make good use of the terrain, and equipment is serviceable or better. There is good elevation change and shot shaping and it's just a fun round. I do see this being a park that could get quite busy, which isn't a bad thing really but is something I would consider a minor con.
Newer baskets might be nice here, but they catch well enough. Similarly, tee signs with maps would be an upgrade, but the other relevant information is all there. While there are some really neat views of the Rock River, the risk of losing a disc to it is very low (pro or con depending on your perspective!). After hole 13, there is a very steep dropoff down to the river; this is probably your best chance of overthrowing and losing one.
For having no garbage cans, this course looked remarkably good. It restores a bit of my faith in humanity. In addition to the dropoff on hole 13, I really liked the downhill throw on hole 12 from high elevation. This does play near the entrance road, which is probably the closest thing to a safety hazard I noted. There is also a "borrow a sled" box on this hill for winter sledding which I've never seen before and thought was so cool, especially since the sleds haven't all been stolen.
Overall, there is a decent level of challenge here, but this course is definitely accessible to a variety of skill levels. There are a few more wooded technical holes, but mostly this is a moderately wooded but still somewhat open course where elevation change and some decent distance are the name of the game.
Navigation is mostly clear but I did embarrass myself and throw the wrong direction off of the 17 tee until someone corrected me. If you look closely there are brass numbers at the front of the tee pad that indicate the direction for the whole, but sometimes these aren't very obvious as they've darkened with age. Usually the proper direction is pretty clear but sometimes multiple baskets are visible.
If you are in the Janesville area, this one is definitely worth a stop. Madison and Milwaukee probably have more high caliber courses, but the Janesville/Evansville area is a respectable disc golf stop and this course is worth playing again.