JCassidy hooked me up with a Fossil Scale on the MP and here is my honest, too-late-at-night, been drinking a bit review.
Why you should skip this review or say something negative about me:
-I'm an outlier. I don't like gateway putters overall. The wizard doesn't work well for me. As I understand it the scale is a wizard with the cool thumbtrack top. I have several wizards and voodoos and don't like them (particularly the voodoos). Chief and Shaman were okay but not in use.
-I like soft putters. I'm unobjectively critical of harder baseline or midline putters.
-I have and throw alot of OS putters. The scale will be up against many other discs in this review.
My surprisingly brief review:
The scale feels okay in my small to medium hands. It's got enough beef for me not to worry about flipping it over on a drive. Not super glidey, more of a range -it putter that goes it's distance and then quits. Average skips for putters in my experience. It looks cool and innovative. RDG is a smaller company and I'm the only guy throwing this. I'm an elitist. I'm a snob. This disc is special and all those noobs got aviars. Ha!
2 Reasons why I'm hesitant to permanently bag it:
(1) It's in between my chosen stabilities. I bag an OS putter (pig, zone, prem jokeri,etc) and a neutral putter that can still take a drive without flipping too much (judge, challenger, shield, etc). To be fair the scale would probably fit in the former, but once it wears I think it will be right inbetween. That would be a perfect compromise putter for a small bag or if you wanted to pack a bunch of scales at different wear levels.
(2) The fossil plastic is inbetween my chosen plastic durabilites. I like a premium/champy OS beef machine putter and a buttery soft neutral putter. The fossil plastic is once again a compromise between the two. I got a hard warden that flies great but the hard plastic didn't penetrate through my stubborn I-know-what-I-like attitude. The fossil isn't that hard, but it's stiff. To be fair, I'm thinking it may wear into a softer more yielding chain-banging machine, but as a fresh disc, it's outside my comfort parameters.
Where I'm at now:
I have it bagged with my soft judge and premium jokeri. I throw it through dangerous vegetation-filled approaches where I'm concerned my judge may grab branches as I hyzer it through. I also putt with it alot immediately after I miss or splash out with my judge to see if I could do better. Usually it looks like: Miss, swear, miss....swear.
I sharpied the Deathly hallows mockingjay on it because you never know when you'll need to relate with a fellow nerd you meet on the course.
http://www.webstore.com/cache/cache_500_1_1_img_15462702_2f6958807a711c46ace3055cb3528a61jpg.gif
My prediction:
While I'm on the fence with the scale (maybe not for long, tar pit scale coming soon), I'm thinking this disc will knock other's socks off. I believe it's an improvement on the wizard (or it's alot closer to what I wanted the wiz to be). The most important thing: The stamps are bananas. I almost bought a whole bunch of Goldblum stamps on RDG's website because I get stupid over cool stamps. My wife would have killed me but I really thought about it. Had the cart loaded and everything. I'm gonna at least one when I get permission (Don't mock me--some things won't suck themselves). Right now I'm leaning towards a softer Goldblum Serpent.
This JCassidy seems like a cool guy and his disc ideas and attitude on this forum are great. I wish him all the luck and hopes he keeps making cool discs (like this lid he's working on)!