I've gone on and on about my love of the Mako3 in other threads, but maybe it bears repeating in this thread.
I came across one in a used disc bin, and it was maybe one of the best training tools for a new player that I can imagine. 172g Champion, purchased in very good condition, and has not changed in the year and a half I've been throwing it.
I have since purchased another champ (used, very good condition) and found a Star (also in vg condition). They all throw very similarly.
For my arm speed, I almost can't get them to roll anny, regardless of how hard I throw them, but they hold the line they're thrown on. This made my Mako3 a particularly cruel teacher to show me when I wasn't throwing dead level. Because of this, I don't think the Mako3 is the best FIRST disc, but a great EARLY disc, once you decide you want to get serious.
I can throw the Mako3 about 250' dead straight. DEAD straight. I made a shot the other day that if it wavered more than 2 degrees through the entire flight I'd be shocked. Unless it reaches absolute stall speed, there is no fade. AT complete stall speed, I sometimes see a bit of fade at the end. This is the highest speed disc I've ever seen with no fade, and because of it, I prefer it for approach shots where maybe a lot of others would use an Aviar or similar 0-fade P&A disc.
It will hold an anhyzer well. It will hold those tricky super subtle anhyzers to the ground at 200'. It will hold a considerably stronger anhyzer, with some panning out at the end, given enough air.
It is NOT the best at hyzers. While it doesn't want to roll beyond flat, it WILL roll to flat if thrown hard enough.
It is absolutely NOT a flex disc. It just flies the line it's put on.
As a new player, I've run my champ into trees maybe 6 times per round, or something like 300-400 times in a year and a half, and the flight has remained consistent.
This is the disc I carry for almost all mid/approach ranged straight and anhyzer angles. That covers a pretty huge range of shots, and makes it, imo, one of the most useful discs in my bag.
It has a permanent place in my bag (you know, for the foreseeable future).