Another update…We made it to Cinci well, Florence, KY actually. We spent yesterday in STL and played Sioux Passage…97 degrees felt like 107. Like one reviewer said "the main obstacle to contend with here is elevation"(and heat as there are few trees). This is a serious understatement. It was up and down rolling hills on the front nine with two semi-technical holes on the front. I expected there to be more verity on the back but it was much the same – it seemed like each hole had an exact or similar counter hole that simply played the opposite direction up/down the last hole. E.g, 2-6, 10-11, 12-13. I know this is logical for design but it kind of made the course a little bland. 13 is the signature holes and was amazing. I threw a 500ft forehand. WOW! Also, none of the signs were marking the correct pin position and that left us guessing a lot (esp 17 where we looked for the basket for 10 min). Honestly, I think the designers went a little crazy with the elevation but it is a great course, just not one I could play every time I went out for a round. Some incredible elevation holes but a low fun factor IMO. I think I'd give it a 4/5.
Today we played Mesker Park in Evansville, IN. It was a very well thought out course with maybe one throw away hole. It had a little bit of everything. I saw one of the other reviews said this course lacked signature holes and I can see his side of the argument. But, there are a high number of really great holes with plenty of character. Of the top of my head - #s 3, 8, 9, 13, 14, 17. It has an island hole(14) that the locals call devils' triangle. If that's not a signature hole I don't know what is. The OB works very well in shaping the holes. The fun factor here was very high. It gets a solid 4/5. I thought about a 4.5 but HCR gets a 4.5/5 and Mesker isn't close to HCR.
So far we have ranked the courses as follows: HCR, Mesker, Lake Bistineau, Sioux Passage