back in November I got a pair of Keen Newport Trail boots from Zappos.com for the winter months. Cost was $110 shipped with free returns.
http://www.zappos.com/keen-newport-trail-brindle-black
Pros: water proof, comfy, good grip but not spectacular, warm,
wide toe box
Cons: maybe not quite high enough, snow sometimes got in form the top, but this is solvable with some good pants, heavy, sole is a bit stiff.
overall I'm very happy with these, they are waterproof, warm, and fit my wide foot well. Its hard to complain to much about a stiff sole when you are talking about a boot, and cold rubber in the winter. also, I had to go with a 14, while i usually wear a 13.
I played in these about once a week from November through February, and they still look great with no visible signs of wear.
just got a pair of Merrell Chameleons for my birthday, so far they are the most comfortable shoe i have ever put on, and wore them for one round and the traction was fantastic, Ill report back on those after some more use. as with the Keens, I had to go with a 14, while i usually wear a 13.