No, some player commentators really do a good job, there's a learning curve.
I still would prefer a commentator who doesn't tell us how "they" would handle the shot. I'd like a pro to be available for insight once in a while, but I think a non player commentator would work better overall. Still... Uli, Nate S are very good. But I certainly agree the Doss's need to stop competing for who can say the most words. I still think it's due to being so far away from the event, no one else is there, it's quiet, etc, so they are over compensating and making "noise" to fill in the silence around them.