Cgkdisc
.:Hall of Fame Member:.
The rules experts on here should know by now that any rule that requires a timing or observation call by the competitors will not be called consistently unless the delineation of Good/Bad is visually obvious in real time AND violation is seen to be egregious enough to warrant a 1-throw penalty.
How many of you set your cruise control at some point over the speed limit you feel is "safe enough" to not be pulled over? Other drivers usually have no problem with you going 5mph over even though it's a violation. In fact, many want you to go even faster over the limit say in Chicago to not slow up traffic flow. You don't make a citizen's arrest and turn yourself in for going over the speed limit. Cops typically don't ticket or even warn for 5mph over except maybe in one traffic light towns and school zones.
We all know technically speeding is a violation but generally agree as a society there's wiggle room. Going even 10mph over a 60mph limit is much like stepping on or beside your mini during a throw. You and the thrower probably see it's a foot fault but it's not enough to deserve a "ticket." Players intuitively understand this. The challenge for rule makers is to figure out how to write a rule that works under this wiggle room idea and meshes with those who want a black & white call.
How many of you set your cruise control at some point over the speed limit you feel is "safe enough" to not be pulled over? Other drivers usually have no problem with you going 5mph over even though it's a violation. In fact, many want you to go even faster over the limit say in Chicago to not slow up traffic flow. You don't make a citizen's arrest and turn yourself in for going over the speed limit. Cops typically don't ticket or even warn for 5mph over except maybe in one traffic light towns and school zones.
We all know technically speeding is a violation but generally agree as a society there's wiggle room. Going even 10mph over a 60mph limit is much like stepping on or beside your mini during a throw. You and the thrower probably see it's a foot fault but it's not enough to deserve a "ticket." Players intuitively understand this. The challenge for rule makers is to figure out how to write a rule that works under this wiggle room idea and meshes with those who want a black & white call.
Last edited: