2023 Reviewer of the Year

[Countchunkula]

Isn't it early to kick off 2023 awards season?

 

[wellsbranch250]

Isn't it early to kick off 2023 awards season?

yes,
the thread is more of a preseason poll or guess. I'm not awarding anything.
if i had included 25 names, like the ncaa, i think countchunkula would be listed.

 

[Countchunkula]

yes,
the thread is more of a preseason poll or guess. I'm not awarding anything.
if i had included 25 names, like the ncaa, i think countchunkula would be listed.

I was totally joking with that post. I'm all for giving kudos to those folks that are improving the body of reviews here. :clap:

It's been years since I made a significant contribution on the review side of things. Hoping to get back on the horse, but all the reasons that led to the decline are still in play.




Also, the line that goes with that Blues Brothers scene immediately came to mind when I read this thread.

 

[ejvogie]

I was totally joking with that post. I'm all for giving kudos to those folks that are improving the body of reviews here. :clap:

It's been years since I made a significant contribution on the review side of things. Hoping to get back on the horse, but all the reasons that led to the decline are still in play.




Also, the line that goes with that Blues Brothers scene immediately came to mind when I read this thread.

New models are in early this year.

 

[wellsbranch250]

I counted up reviews for Valk, Mash, and yourself, so after I get past harr0410 and Craig I feel like rest will feel like 10 minutes worth of time in comparison.

So how far did you get? Id be interested in seeing how the tallies added up.

 

[Tyler V]

So how far did you get? Id be interested in seeing how the tallies added up.

I'm going to get into it this week. This past week is typically the busiest of the semester in my office but this week will be much more relaxed.

I also want to recount some of the larger reviewers as I'm noticing the final tallies of the individual years added up do not always match the overall review number DGCR has. Would there be a reason for that? Deleted reviewed from the past?

 

[Cerealman]

you and cerealman both could run away with it. Darkhorse candidates

I see the gauntlet has been thrown down.

I get it; my reviews written to courses played score (0.26) isn't high enough. Plus, I'm only about 25 unique voters away from Diamond. :O

Put me in the game, coach! Here you go: https://www.dgcoursereview.com/reviews.php?id=10168

 

[Surge5]

Plus, I'm only about 25 unique voters away from Diamond. :O

Good, at least someone's getting close to Diamond. I still need 129 uniques :wall:

 

[Cerealman]

Good, at least someone's getting close to Diamond. I still need 129 uniques :wall:

I'm fortunate. I wrote about a dozen reviews in the early days (2008-2012) that weren't very detailed or good, but I snagged some unique thumbs from DGCR users that perhaps haven't frequented the site in a decade.

 

[Tyler V]

Alrighty, here's the top review contributor for each year from 2008 to 2022:

2008: Innovadude, 129
2009: Dave242, 220
2010: mashnut, 223
2011: mashnut, 158
2012: mashnut, 149
2013: reposado, 109
2014: A TIE, with Valkyrie Kid and mndiscg each with 102
2015: The Valkyrie Kid, 146
2016: The Valkyrie Kid, 172
2017: The Valkyrie Kid, 158
2018: wellsbranch250, 149
2019: MrFrosty, 117
2020: MrFrosty, 175
2021: Shadrach3, 111
2022: Shadrach3, 101

Some things I found interesting:
1. While never getting the top spot, harr0410 provided the second most reviews in '09, '11, and '12.
2. Two particularly close races were in 2018, where Valkyrie Kid is 2nd by 2 reviews, and 2022, where HyooMac was just 4 reviews behind Shadrach.
3. DiscGolfCraig is another notable name to not get the top spot in a given year, simply because his reviews are spread out more, with many years or 30+ reviews.

2007 is an interesting year that will take me more time to lock in a winner, as the review counts are just much smaller since the site was brand new. I plan to fill out top 25s for each year, and will also catch up on 2023 to track this year's top review counts as well. I still have a lot to look through, but so far, I have HyooMac leading with 17 reviews, followed by Surge5, Wellsbranch250, and DiscGolfCraig with 10 each, and DFrah with 9.

 

[wellsbranch250]

Alrighty, here's the top review contributor for each year from 2008 to 2022:

2008: Innovadude, 129
2009: Dave242, 220
2010: mashnut, 223
2011: mashnut, 158
2012: mashnut, 149
2013: reposado, 109
2014: A TIE, with Valkyrie Kid and mndiscg each with 102
2015: The Valkyrie Kid, 146
2016: The Valkyrie Kid, 172
2017: The Valkyrie Kid, 158
2018: wellsbranch250, 149
2019: MrFrosty, 117
2020: MrFrosty, 175
2021: Shadrach3, 111
2022: Shadrach3, 101

Some things I found interesting:
1. While never getting the top spot, harr0410 provided the second most reviews in '09, '11, and '12.
2. Two particularly close races were in 2018, where Valkyrie Kid is 2nd by 2 reviews, and 2022, where HyooMac was just 4 reviews behind Shadrach.
3. DiscGolfCraig is another notable name to not get the top spot in a given year, simply because his reviews are spread out more, with many years or 30+ reviews.

2007 is an interesting year that will take me more time to lock in a winner, as the review counts are just much smaller since the site was brand new. I plan to fill out top 25s for each year, and will also catch up on 2023 to track this year's top review counts as well. I still have a lot to look through, but so far, I have HyooMac leading with 17 reviews, followed by Surge5, Wellsbranch250, and DiscGolfCraig with 10 each, and DFrah with 9.

interesting stats Tyler. I am surprised to see that 100 reviews has been hit every year except 2007. To be on a 100 review pace, one would have to be a 20 reviews right now. although, winter always seems to be at slower pace.

 

[Tyler V]

interesting stats Tyler. I am surprised to see that 100 reviews has been hit every year except 2007. To be on a 100 review pace, one would have to be a 20 reviews right now. although, winter always seems to be at slower pace.

Yeah, late Spring and Summer are definitely when numbers pick up, so we could definitely still see the century mark hit again.

 

[HyooMac]

Yeah, late Spring and Summer are definitely when numbers pick up, so we could definitely still see the century mark hit again.

It won't be me. I've peaked - the daytrip supply is running out!

 

[wellsbranch250]

It won't be me. I've peaked - the daytrip supply is running out!

When my daytrip glass hit empty, weekend tripper was born. It never runs dry

 

[DFrah]

I hate to admit it, but after my round at a local park earlier this evening I was just going to go home...but then I thought of this thread and decided to go bag a new school 9er.

 

[Shadrach3]

Alrighty, here's the top review contributor for each year from 2008 to 2022:

Some surprises here for me! Specifically, that harr0140 isn't anywhere on the list in first (a la Tyler's observation) and that wellsbranch only topped it once. It will be cool to see the top 10/25 per year! And I honestly had no clue I was setting the pace in 2022, thought several guys were out-reviewing me. Can guarantee it won't happen again in 2023.

 

[Tyler V]

Some surprises here for me! Specifically, that harr0140 isn't anywhere on the list in first (a la Tyler's observation) and that wellsbranch only topped it once. It will be cool to see the top 10/25 per year! And I honestly had no clue I was setting the pace in 2022, thought several guys were out-reviewing me. Can guarantee it won't happen again in 2023.

Top 25 lists are in progress because I want to know as well.

 

[Tyler V]

Some surprises here for me! Specifically, that harr0140 isn't anywhere on the list in first (a la Tyler's observation) and that wellsbranch only topped it once. It will be cool to see the top 10/25 per year! And I honestly had no clue I was setting the pace in 2022, thought several guys were out-reviewing me. Can guarantee it won't happen again in 2023.

Also, Harr and wells are very high up for multiple years - it's interesting to see some of the higher review count holders who are really spread out over the years that are not at the top of any list, but still have plenty of reviews each year.

 

[adlacro]

I had 28 in 2007, I also believe that was the first year dgcoursereview.com was established. Hope that helps the quest, Tyler J.

 

[Tyler V]

I had 28 in 2007, I also believe that was the first year dgcoursereview.com was established. Hope that helps the quest, Tyler J.

That's currently the highest number I have found in 2007, and you also currently have the 6th highest number I have found for 2023. No one else is on both of those tentative lists.