Smigles
* Ace Member *
Ok so just to warn you, this entire thread comes from the amateur championships that just finished and my disliking of those sandbaggers.
So it seems to me that the system we have at the moment ( you can pick for yourself which cathegory you want to register for at the PDGA ) is great for letting people play where and who they want, but it is not realy separating players by their level. There are people who play worse rated tournaments at majors ( in the pro league ) than what the winners of AM tournaments usually play.
One effect that this has on me is that I can not take anyone serious who does not play open pro. ( well except for age protected groups and for ladies... ) But all those rec and am and whatever they wanna call themself players, i can not take them serious at all. As persons maybe, that depends on their personality, but not as discgolfers, competitors or sportsmen. That is of course my personal opinion, but I can not be the only one who thinks like that, rigth?
The problem I see with forcing people to play in certain cathegories depending on their rating is that this can lead to some real REAL sandbagging and that people probably dont like it.
My solution would be quite simple : Make 3 cathegories : casual, ambitioned and pro ( of course age and sex protected sub cathegories ). Pro are only the touring pros. those who are actually sponsored and make money with playing disc golf ( as it is in every other sport ffs. ). Ambitioned is what is called "pro" today, and all the others go into "casual".
Casual tournaments can only ask for starting fees to cover the organisation cost. No prices, no trophies, no profit for the organisers, just the absolutely minimum cost for a fun round of throwing plastic. Which is what playing in the casual division is about, having fun throwing discs. There is no mixing of casual and other events. ( And no, there will be no "casual world championship". There is only ONE world champion, and if you wanna call yourself world champ, you better beat the touring pros and the other realy good players! )
Ambitioned and Pro will hold mixed events where they battle for the cash and the glory and the titles and everything.
So it seems to me that the system we have at the moment ( you can pick for yourself which cathegory you want to register for at the PDGA ) is great for letting people play where and who they want, but it is not realy separating players by their level. There are people who play worse rated tournaments at majors ( in the pro league ) than what the winners of AM tournaments usually play.
One effect that this has on me is that I can not take anyone serious who does not play open pro. ( well except for age protected groups and for ladies... ) But all those rec and am and whatever they wanna call themself players, i can not take them serious at all. As persons maybe, that depends on their personality, but not as discgolfers, competitors or sportsmen. That is of course my personal opinion, but I can not be the only one who thinks like that, rigth?
The problem I see with forcing people to play in certain cathegories depending on their rating is that this can lead to some real REAL sandbagging and that people probably dont like it.
My solution would be quite simple : Make 3 cathegories : casual, ambitioned and pro ( of course age and sex protected sub cathegories ). Pro are only the touring pros. those who are actually sponsored and make money with playing disc golf ( as it is in every other sport ffs. ). Ambitioned is what is called "pro" today, and all the others go into "casual".
Casual tournaments can only ask for starting fees to cover the organisation cost. No prices, no trophies, no profit for the organisers, just the absolutely minimum cost for a fun round of throwing plastic. Which is what playing in the casual division is about, having fun throwing discs. There is no mixing of casual and other events. ( And no, there will be no "casual world championship". There is only ONE world champion, and if you wanna call yourself world champ, you better beat the touring pros and the other realy good players! )
Ambitioned and Pro will hold mixed events where they battle for the cash and the glory and the titles and everything.