Got a $50 Amazon gift card from my employer for a birthday (love small companies) and decided on some WP DG shoes. Went with
Merrell All Out Terra Ice WPs.
Ended up paying $7 after $50 gift card. The size 11.5 fits very true to size, very light, the grip is INCREDIBLE, after 2 months of heavy use in everything from morning dew - to standing water - to downpours, they are very well waterproofed. I walked through water over the tongue - just short of the ankle - and never had a drop leak through. Very good stuff. The only pair I've had that were this well waterproofed were heavy hiking boots and I didn't want that weight, nor the high low-calf/ankle boots.
Very happy with these Merrells over any Keens, Timberlands, UnderArmors, or Columbias I've owned. Keens seem to be the only shoes I've tried that are even close.