Rock climbing women are generally attractive; worst case, a butterface (yes, I know that's a terrible thing to say).
Her feet are not ugly. Maybe she's too busy being active and writing funny things to get a pedicure - get over it.
She's educated, funny and engaging. Most people on here could do a lot worse.
Regarding the vegetarian thing: 1) it's a theory, 2) it shouldn't be a dealbreaker for most dudes, and 3) she mocked the ex-boyfriend for being a crunchy-granola type, so she will at least have a sense of humor about it.
All that said, who cares if she's attractive or willing/available for dating(or more)? If it was a dude we'd still just be laughing about the story, which is funny in its own right.
Thanks for sharing the saga of platebee with us.